Hobby Lobby in West Bend has a really good variety of items in their large store. The store also carries several Christian items such as stickers and stamps with verses on them. (kind of a rarety in most stores)
I would recommend this store to any crafter. By the way, you can go to the store for home decorating needs as well. You wouldn't necessarily think of a craft store for decor, but they do have some nice items for decor.
more