I went here recently and man, was it difficult to find (exiting off of 35 onto 38 1/2 street) but definitely worth the trouble! The Gelato was great, I got to try Creme Caramel and Pistachio and both were absolutely delicious! It was definitely worth the confusion to get there!
The people here are very nice and accomodating and the place has that "corner ice cream shop" feel. The place is dimly lit but still gives a very personal touch. If I had kids, I'd definitely bring them here! Lower fat then regular ice cream and tastier too! Word of advice, eat your gelato quick! Mine melted too fast :-(.
Pros: Great Gelato, Good service, Nice locals
Cons: , small signs
more