There are at least 15 better steakhouses in NYC than this restaurant that somehow manages to be simplistically pretentious.
Appetizers were OK, steak was not as good as what I would have prepared at home on the grill.
If you want a better steak -- and the ability to choose your favorite cut of meat (porterhouse only at Luger's) try Smith and Wollensky's on 3rd Avenue. If you want a nice steakhouse atmosphere with comfortable surroundings and a steak superior to Luger's, try Keens Steakhouse in the mid-30s.
more