I won't say Peter Luger is the best steak I've ever had, but it is certainly up there. How anyone can give the food anything less than an 8 (unless they don't like steak with pink on the inside) completely boggles my mind. The party of 8 I dined with were all agog at how good the seak was. The servers were all helpful and good-natured, although we ate upstairs and had a lot of the younger staff, so that might have been it. Decor is old, but the bathrooms are clean and updated.
If you're in NYC, you do have to take a trip out to W'burg once to try it. I've had a lot of steak in this city, and Luger is one you have to try.
Pros: Steak, Steak, Did I mention Steak
Cons: A bit overhyped
more