Good luck finding a better porterhouse for 2; Luger's is maybe 1% better, but RPT's cottage fires are unique and NO ONE can touch them.
Great Filet. Wine list is very good (Sparks is better) with some good values. Occasional wine specials include magnums of Silver Oak.
Overall, no one in NYC can touch RPT, including Old Homestead. Try RPT in Fair Lawn, less crowded.
more