I've been to all 3 RPT locations. Although I prefer Mahwah (less crowded than Edgewater, cozier than Fairlawn) the food is consistently excellent with with a broad menu, and professional wait staff. The wait is usually minimal with reservation at Mahwah. I have not had better steak in NYC!
Pros: Great food, broad menu, good service
Cons: Edgewater too crowded, Fairlawn too big
more