Peter Luger's is a wonderfully unique experience and has the best porterhouse in NYC, period. While the waits frequently run to over an hour, even with a reservation, the food is definitely worth it. Fit in and order off menu - my faves are the porterhouse, the sinfully thick and juicy bacon, and the best pecan pie I've ever had. Tomatoes and onions are thick and popular, the cheesecakes wonderful. The service is distinctly old school New York and charming. Ambience is a bit coarse - don't pop the question here - and location suck but hey, you know why you're here - it's the food, schmuck!
Pros: Food, Service, Food Again!
Cons: Location, Wait Time
more