I recently visited Tupelo Honey and was amazed. The Chef's tasting menu is a great value - reasonably priced compared to what you might pay for similar fare in the City. The tasting menu consisted of a soup, appetizer, fish, meat and dessert. I loved the tasting menu as it allowed me to try a little of everything and I would have had a hard time deciding between entrees!
The service was friendly and helpful, the manager even bought us a round of drinks. The ambiance is unique in a good way. Tupelo also has a well stocked bar and knowledgable bartenders. The restaurant draws a popular crowd after 11. I definitely recommend Tupelo for anyone making a trip out to Long Island.
Pros: Food quality, Ambiance, Service
Cons: A little pricey
more