I've been fortunate to have eaten at some of the (arguably) finest steak houses throughout the United States. This also includes more than my share of places in N.Y.C., and I must say that Peter Luger's Steak House is way over rated. In my opinion Mark Joseph's steak house, off of Peck Slip in lower Manhattan is the (#1) one. The owner Charlie is a former employee of Peter Luger's who ventured out on his own and surpassed his former master. The steaks are just as good, with an assortment of tasty side dishes that make Peter Luger's menu look like the slip in a fortune cookie. Moreover, the staff and ambiance are both warm and inviting.
Pros: Good steaks
Cons: Limited menu, Drab ambiance, Unfriendly menu
more