Baffling how some places consistently get high reviews. The porterhouse steak was very good, excellent crust and flavor, but no way is this the best steak house in NY. Michael Jordans is clearly better, for one. I have also had far superior steaks at other restaurants. Given the horrible location, no decor and poor side dishes, I don't see why anyone would choose Peter Lugers for a steak dinner.
Pros: Good Porterhouse
Cons: Side Dishes, Atmosphere
more