The Prairie Star is far from inconsistent. Sounds like you haven't dined there at all. I go on a regular basis and find that the food is outstanding, the service is excelllent and the view is even better. I dream about the rock shrimp relleno and curry mayonnaise. The new Pastry chef rocks!!
I had the four layer chocolate cake last time I was there - yummm! Ask for Tracy as your server - you can't go wrong.
Pros: best view in town, Great steaks, Superb wine list
Cons: pricey for everyday, long drive
more