If you can get over the fact that they are located next door to University Massage, Trilussa's is the number one Italian restaurant in the Triangle. The initmate, home-like atmosphere complements the food and wine, and the service is impeccable. Parking can be tricky, as is always the case in Chapel Hill, but it's worth circling the block a few times. Try the tortellini and the house chianti - my personal favorites.
Pros: food, wine, service
Cons: parking, next door neighbors
more