I have to weigh in. Everyone's said it already, but I'll say it again for you folks just joining us here: Lucky Baldwin's is a GREAT place for a beer. Wonderful selection of microbrews and exotics on tap, plus a huge variety of bottles. The service is spotty, as other people have mentioned, and the food is just okay--except for their chips, which might be the best I've ever had. If at all possible, sit outside in the beer garden--indoors tends to be noisy and less comfortable. The crowd tends towards those in the know who eschew the usual Old Town scene in favor of hoisting a few pints.
Pros: beer selection, beer garden
Cons: spotty service, mediocre food
more