We went to Buffalo Billiards last weekend and it was great across the board.
It has a great look and atmosphere, lots of pool tables (it's deceptively big -- don't miss the upstairs lounge), surprisingly good food, and, needless to say, lots and lots to drink. There were a bunch of couches and chairs on which to sit and relax, and the noise level is perfect -- you're not in a library, but there's not too much noise to drown out a good conversation. Last but not least, the service was particularly impressive.
There was a diverse crowd -- it definitely seems like the type of place where lots of different types can co-exist peacefully.
Pros: Big and comfortable, Lots of pool tables, Good crowd
more