We ate at South Street Cafe once and ordered out a couple times when we first moved to Fanwood. However, my husband (who is Italian) hates their pizza. The subs and sandwiches are a little better. Service is slow. Once when we ordered for pick up we found that they had given our pizza to someone else because they thought we took too long to get there. Now we order from Alfonso's in Scotch Plains. My husband likes it much better and no problems with service.
more