I've been going to this place since I was in Kindergarten in 1987 and it hasn't changed since. I still love going there and watching all the kids from the High School hanging out after school. The pizza is fantastic, best anywhere in the area. The salads are very good as well, and the sanwiches are just as good. The pasta dishes are good as well, but the truth is that if I've been there 1,000 times, 990 of those times I order the pizza. The student special is still a great deal with two slices and a large coke (you can choose small, medium, large or extra large) for $4.25. When you go in for the first time, get the student special with Pepperoni, and a Cherry Coke. I don't know what they do, but the Cherry Coke just seems to be better here than anywhere else on the planet. As for the atmosphere, it's always great, though it can very crowded if there is a high school football game that night (Tony's is located right next to San Marino High School) and if you go after school gets out. The parking lot can also be tricky, but there is plenty of street parking and another lot across the street. All in all, one of my favorite restaraunts.
Pros: The food, the price, the atmosphere.
Cons: Tends to be crowded after school and before high school football games, parking lot is small.
more