The Toys Time Forgot

Claim
marker

137 Cherry St E
Canal Fulton, OH 44614

marker
(330) 854-1700
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Related categories:

Used Merchandise Stores

Photos
The Toys Time Forgot - Canal Fulton, OH
The Toys Time Forgot - Canal Fulton, OH
Reviews
( 3 )
( 3 )
( 1 )
( 1 )
( 0 )

Best

Toys that Time Forgot is a great store. I had an amaing experience shopping there. Dan and his staff were very nice and they knew all about the items I was searching for. They eve...

Worst

OK Place, but as someone who deals at toy shows & on ebay his selection is terribly overpriced and it looks like they collect more toys than they sell. One item was a 1988 Star Tr...

Worth a 6 hour drive 11/29/2011

Toys that Time Forgot is a great store. I had an amaing experience shopping there. Dan and his staff were very nice and they knew all about the items I was searching for. They even made sure to carefully wrap everything before they would let me leave the store. I don't know what the other reviewer on here was talking about. I guess he was mad that Dan didn't follow him around like a car salesman and kiss his butt. I prefer to be allowed to browse on my own until I ask for help. When I did ask, Fred (a very nice guy) followed me around telling me all about the items and even went searching for stuff I couldn't find. I've never been treated so well when shopping anywhere else. I consider myself a Star Wars expert, and I brought along two very reliable price guides. I can say that Dan's prices fall well within resonable, and frankly some of them were really good deals ($3 white vintage stormtroopers- Army building!). His carded figures were about 10% too high, but guess what? They were in more

Nice store but wayyy overpriced. Stick to ebay, it's cheaper! 9/15/2011

OK Place, but as someone who deals at toy shows & on ebay his selection is terribly overpriced and it looks like they collect more toys than they sell. One item was a 1988 Star Trek kit that is easy to come by in it's original relaease on ebay for $10.00 today and has since been reissued and currently in stores, was overpriced to $50.00. My wife, daughter & I were the only ones in the store and the owner was more interested in the way his employee was displaying the toys (I guess he was too busy to say hello).Vintage carded Star Wars figures were being hung from the ceiling by clips, damaging the cards instead of placing them in pro-tech cases, and his R2-D2 Cooler was full of used SW figures that were no cheaper than 10.00 and were filthy (I had to use a wipe for my hands once i got back to the car). Stay away from this schiester as he takes advantage of his customers nostalgia and ignorance of the collectible market. more

Something for everyone! 9/10/2010

I've been going to this store for over 15 years for vintage items to put into my various collections and let me say that some of the best pieces I've owned have come from Toys Time Forgot. Dan is always acquiring vintage collections of all types and it has been a privilege to be consulted on many of them. I have seen a lot of very nice vintage pieces come in and, shortly after, go into the hands of very happy collectors - including myself. more

Toys Time Forgot is awsesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 8/10/2009

I've been doing business with Dan and his crew for years.They always have awesome things many of which are very hard to find.This store is great to go buy things or if you just want to go look around.You may spot something from your childhood that brings back old memories.Stop in and check out you'll love this store. more

LS 9/30/2008

Great vintage toys. Nice place to check out. Vintage toys from 1940s to 1980s. Lots of nostalgia. Recommend while passing through stop and see. Check it out. more

A stroll down memory lane 7/30/2005

Remember your favorite toys from when y ou were a child? Want to show your kids what you played with when you were there age? Then this is the store for you. They have anything and everything that you can think of. I found severl things that I p layed with and still have. great store and fantastic staff. more

The Toys Time Forgot 7/26/2005

What a cool toy store. I found this store accidentally and I am so glad I did. There are so many old toys here, ones I remember from my own childhood. I like to take my son here because he is interested in toys from the past. We could spend all day here looking at the various toys. This is a fun place to go for a walk down memory lane and to make new memories for your children. more
< Previous 1 Next >
Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

Get your toys back!

Owner Message
  • Step back in time and recapture your childhood memories with over 4,000 square feet of vintage toys from the 50's, classic toys from the 60's, cool toys from the 70's and top toys from the 80's. We specialize in Baby Boomer toys, movie and TV memorabilia, comic books and collector cards, dolls and action figures. We are voted Ohio's #1 vintage toy store since 1998. Come in and check out the toys your mom threw out or find a unique gift for the special loved one in your life. Free appraisals available.. Vintage toys,TV and movie memorabilia,board games,action figures (Star Wars,Star Trek,GI Joe,Universal Monsters,TMNT,He-Man,Thundercats,Sideshow,Hot Toys),comic books,lunchboxes,tin wind-ups,battery ops,robots,sci-fi toys,die cast cars,dolls and collector cards.

Additional information
  • Hours: Sun 12pm-5pm, Tue-Sat 11am-8pm
badge