top 10

Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant

Claim
marker

41 City Island Ave (at Rochelle Street)
Bronx, NY 10464

marker
(718) 509-6367
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant - Bronx, NY
Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant - Bronx, NY
Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant - Bronx, NY
Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant - Bronx, NY
Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant - Bronx, NY
Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant - Bronx, NY
Videos
Reviews
( 134 )
( 17 )
( 1 )
( 6 )
( 8 )

Best

Ambiance Is Great. Food & Drinks even better.. My wife and I had cocktails and dinner at Sammy's on City Island a few days ago and as always we were very happy with the experienc...

Worst

Went to Sammy's in December, 2009 and really enjoyed the food and service. On Fri., 9/10/10, the family wanted to go out for a seafood/fish dinner and everyone agreed on Sammy's. ...

Awesome place 5/7/2009

Ate dinner here this evening, and was very impressed overall. The place has a nice ambience, without being pretentious. Service was very attentive and helpful. The wine selection was substantial without being overly pricey. The food was the star though. Our dishes were outstanding, from the mahi tuna to the baby back ribs and halibut mains. They were prepared to perfection and were delicious. I wholeheartedly recommend this place...\r \r Pros: absolutely the freshest food Cons: Very Busy more
Reply | Report abuse |

AThere is Nothing better than fresh seafood 5/4/2009

If you are looking for some fresh fish and many varieties, Sammy's Fishbox on City Island in the Bronx is the place . You can get Grouper,Flounder,Mahi Mahi,Tuna and many more selections.They fixed them either broiled,fried,pan seared,or sauteed, or baked.Its so good to actually taste fresh fish and have it cooked correctly.We will be back. Pros: Fresh fish and tender beef more
Reply | Report abuse |

Worth the drive every time 5/4/2009

This is the best place for fresh seafood & steaks. We drive 2 hours from Staten Island just to eat here. Every time we have eaten here the food is great & service is top notch. Watch out for the Mojito's they will sneak up on you\r Pros: Food is outstanding more
Reply | Report abuse |

Lobster Heaven 5/1/2009

I have been here several times and have tried many different dishes and they have all been excellent! The food also comes out very fast! I would especially recommend their famous fried Jumbo shrimp which comes with various other items, like king crab legs, snow legs, baby back ribs and more. I couldn't believe the variety of combinations our table tried many and they all were great. I can't wait to retiurn to Sammy's again and again. Pros: Freshest seafood ever Cons: long wait sometimes more
Reply | Report abuse |

Loyal customer since they opened 4/29/2009

I have been going to Sammy's since they first opened in a small shack like restaurant in City Island and have never been disappointed. The food is always fresh, the service friendly, and the prices reasonable. Sammy's has a casual atmosphere with great seafood and even the Ribs and steaks are fantastic. Their fried foods are the best on the planet and are worth the splurge! Pros: Fresh food prepared perfectly more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Food and Staff 4/26/2009

Highly recommend the selection of fresh catch of the day and the New England Clam chowder as well as the huge selection of surf and Turf combinations, You dream it and Sammy's menu has it. I never get tired of comiong back tpo try something different. Try a Mojito at the friendly and fun bar or ask Amad to make you one of his specials. Fresh seafood, prof & friendly Staff and good music make this place easy to recommend Pros: No Doubt the Best Seafood around more
Reply | Report abuse |

Top of Top 4/23/2009

Nearly every dish that lands on the table is overwhelming, , but a few standout starters include roasted lump crab cakes with a 20-year-old Ambroshante sherry based sauce, the Maine lobster bisque and the classic house fresh salad were perfect. For the main course, fennel-butter basted twin south African lobster tails melts away and fresh, flavorful fishes like Alaskan halibut or wild salmon will not disappoint the most discerning seafood connoisseur. I can,t want to return to Sammy's next week for my birthday. Pros: Fresh Fish, lobster and king crab legs more
Reply | Report abuse |

Definitely The Place to Go for Fresh Seafood 4/21/2009

I've taken out of town friends here twice and it was great both times. It's got a classy, warm log cabiney decor -- but the best thing is the \r fresh seafood.\r One time we went crazy and got a huge platter of shellfish-- on my second visit I had the best piece of fish I've had in a long time.\r I highly recommend this place !\r Pros: Fresh Fresh fish more
Reply | Report abuse |

The top of my list 4/19/2009

I went there with my friend who was visiting me. The service was excellent and very professional. Seafood was nice, fresh, well prepared. It might be a little pricy to go every day. . But overall I am very satisfied with what I paid and I had a giant doggie bag to take home and food for two meals.\r Pros: great lobster and swordfish Cons: very busy more
Reply | Report abuse |

Wonderful Evening 4/15/2009

I go to Sammy’s quite often and always find it to be great. While they may slip every now and again, keep in mind that this place is ALWAYS very busy; they remain a great sea-food restaurant. We have always had the most professional service. The manager is always the most approachable manager I’ve found anywhere. He once heard it was our anniversary and came out with two glasses of champagne and balloons and congratulated us. It was a very nice touch to a wonderful evening. \r Pros: Food and service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Always great 4/14/2009

I have never had a bad meal at Sammy’s Their calamari and their blue cheese salad are the best I've ever had. Their steak and seafood is phenomenal. It's amazing that many people don't know about this place. \r The atmosphere is pleasant but not ritzy, so it's a good middle-ground place to go when you want great food without the pretentiousness. They have some open air seating, which is nice in the summer. The staff is also extremely friendly. Sammy’s is a great place to meet with clients or dates.\r Pros: Food and service more
Reply | Report abuse |

a winner 4/14/2009

We were seated promptly as we arrived for our reservation, even though we were a few minutes late due to traffic. The food was wonderful and the waitstaff very helpful in describing the selections and their favorites when we were unsure of what we wanted. As we were with an out of town guest, our request for a table next to the fireplace was accomodated. Pros: king crab legs and crab cakes more
Reply | Report abuse |

Super night out! 4/12/2009

Quite frankly the best restaurant experience I have had anywhere. Celbrity crowd, great people watching, awesome food and service. An interior that makes you never want to leave, they not only have the finest seafood dishes ever, but on my last visit I tried one of Sammy's Prime shell steaks, that were as good any any of the city's top steak restauarnt I've eaten at Pros: Great Food, Creative presentation, Nice atmosphere more
Reply | Report abuse |

Awsome Maine Lobster 4/10/2009

First time writing a review, I went to Sammy?s Fishbox on City Island on Saturday night with some friends. We were greeted promptly by a very pretty hostess and seated shortly after that. There was a buzz of conversation all around; everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. As I looked around to see what others were eating as our server Larry greeted us. He suggested we try the Martinis, I tried the Apple and my friends tried an assortment of awesome mojitos needless to say we had many. The menu has so many wonderful items I could not decide. Again, Larry came to the rescue and suggested an assortment of fantastic Appetizers followed by the best stuffed giant Maine lobsters ever Overall a great experience, young and knowledgeable server with personality. Will be back with more friends...Thank you Sammy?s \r \r Pros: Everything I look for in a great restaurant more
Reply | Report abuse |

A Memorable Dinning Experience 4/9/2009

I recently had dinner at Sammy’s Fishbox on a Friday and had one of those memorable dining experiences that seem to be few and far between lately in this city. From the moment we were greeted by the lovely hostess we felt so welcome by the staff. Our server was very efficient and knowledgeable without being intrusive.\r We began our dinner with appetizers that were outstanding. Our main courses continued to impress. We had Swordfish and South African Lobster tails, again, so yummy! We split a dessert and almost wished we had had another as our Chocolate Raspberry Fudge cake as surprisingly one of the best desserts we have had in awhile.\r We will be back and continue to go back.\r Pros: Fresh seafood, great service, innovative cocktail menu more
Reply | Report abuse |

Superior establishment 4/8/2009

Everything that we ordered was well-prepared and delicious. The scallops and crab cake cakes were excellent. Our wait-person was very attentive and even came back to the table to ask me if a certain ingredient in my meal was acceptable, so she was very mindful of dietary restrictions. An overall great experience, and we plan on returning. We also had the best Pina Colada ever, tall frozen and delicious Pros: Great food, great service Cons: can't think of any more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Seafood Restaurant in New York City 4/7/2009

This is one of my favorite restaurants but definitely my favorite seafood restaurant. Fisherman that we know love eating here and ordering from their wide selection of fresh fish. That's all you need to know. We love it so much. The food is just awesome. My favorites include the whole baked Red Snapper (always must order it) The main dishes are delicious. My favorite dessert is the mile high chocolate layer cake.. Yum!! Pros: Food and friendly staff more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Seafood ever 4/4/2009

Sammy’s is the place to go if you want a no-frills, old fashioned seafood dinner. The fish is amazing. Even my husband, who generally prefers steak, really enjoyed the fish here. The Fried giant shrimp are fantastic as well. Seriously treat yourself. The prices may seem a little high but are completely worth it. I would rank it as one of the top three seafood houses in New England.\r Pros: Freshest fish Cons: always quite busy more
Reply | Report abuse |

Giant Shrimp, Maine Lobster and ahi - oh my! 3/29/2009

I just got back from Sam's on City Island. Another great experience. I had 6 kumamota oysters and a crab feast. I'm in heaven. Everytime I go to Sams I tell myself I'm going to try something else but I just love the Crab feast. I did try the hallibut with the other night. That was to die for. So good. I'm a creature of habit though and the crab is my thing It's a great place to go, the food is excellent and I'm always treated nice. I highly recommend it. Pros: Food and service Cons: very busy, sometimes the wait a little long more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fantastic food, decor, service 3/10/2009

I?m a Brooklyn born girl and this place is my home for seafood and ribs in the great NYC. Great raw bar, very fresh seafood, I especially love the giant lobster stuffed with crabmeat baked to perfection. The service as well was excellent . Even the valet was good. Go here.\r \r Pros: Fantastic food, decor, service Cons: Pricey but worth it more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Next >
Menu for Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

City Island restaurant with expansive seafood menu, feast platters, children's menu and separate bar--open late.

Owner Message

  • About Sammy's

    41 City Island Avenue, Bronx New York 10464

    When You visit Sammy's Fish Box on City Island, you can expect impeccable service, unforgettable meals and captivating ambiance. Executive chef and owner Sam Chernin takes pride in showcasing spectacularly flavorful yet unpretentious just out of the water seafood dishes. Try our legendary Feast Platters. The Italian Feast for two features extremely generous portions of Whole live Maine Lobster, Jumbo Succulent Shrimp, Mussels and three kinds of Crab served with our famous garlic or marinara sauce over hot steaming fresh pasta.

    You should also try one of our Surf and Turf selections from New York's largest " Surf & Turf Menu" as well as our hard shell fresh only live Maine lobsters, Jumbo King crab Legs and the largest Snow Crab Legs offered anywhere. Sammy's also features the world best Baby Back Ribs, Prime Black Ang

Editorial

  • City Island restaurant with expansive seafood menu, feast platters, children's menu and separate bar--open late.

  • 3/22/2006 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Sun-Thu 11:30am-2am Fri-Sat 11:30am-4am
  • Payments: American Express, Discover, Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods: City Island
badge