top 10

Old Bag Of Nails Pub

Claim
marker

663 High St
Columbus, OH 43085

marker
(614) 436-5552
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 6 )
( 5 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 2 )

Best

This place has the best fish and chips. The appetizers are awesome love the fried pickles. Dont know how anyone could not like this place. Great Prices!!!! Pros: Too many t...

Worst

I was sorely disappointed! I had the Fish and Chips, Long Johns does a better job. The place was empty and I see why. People raved about it so I tried it and I will tell everyone ...

Great, Friendly spott 11/12/2008

Despite the other reviews, I found this to be a great spot for a good meal. The fish and chips arguably the best in the city. It has the Cheers(tv show) atmosphere to it. The staff was very polite. I would reccomend this place to anyone I meet. I went to the high street location. more
Reply | Report abuse |

This was a Major Mistake 8/16/2008

I was sorely disappointed! I had the Fish and Chips, Long Johns does a better job. The place was empty and I see why. People raved about it so I tried it and I will tell everyone I know NOT to go there. The waitstaff was rude and DIRTY, Hard Road location, and the service was weak. People who compare this to English Pubs have never been to a real Pub. I can't believe how bad this place was!! Pros: Are you kidding Cons: Overpriced, unclean, unsanitary bathroom more
Reply | Report abuse |

GREAT FOOD 2/1/2008

This place has the best fish and chips. The appetizers are awesome love the fried pickles. Dont know how anyone could not like this place. Great Prices!!!! Pros: Too many to list more
Reply | Report abuse |

awful 1/27/2007

My girlfriend and I stopped by the Westerville location. The food was aweful. Her medium steak was crispy and I had to cut the black burnt stuff of my salmon to make it edible. We both finished our drinks halfway through dinner (we ate at the bar), but were never offered any seconds. The bartenders it seems was too busy fussing over the restaurant manager who was sitting next too us having a few too many in her own establishment. Definitely one of the worst dining experiences of my 40 year life!!! Pros: good locaiton Cons: bad service bad food more
Reply | Report abuse |

Rustic Burger with steak fries. House salad with house dressing 9/11/2006

If I die and go to heaven, I hope there is a Bag of Nails Resturant there!!! Was introduced to this establishment by a friend and it is one of my all time favorite places to eat. Pros: Food is very good. I could eat the potato soup and house salad everyday. Like the bigger building in Gahanna. Cons: Small building on Nelson and E. Broad. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fantastic local bar/restaurant 5/4/2005

this is a fantastic little restaurant in the heart of Worthington. the waitstaff is very knowledgeable, and the food is excellent! if you have a chance, sit at the bar and let yourself be entertained by the banter of one of the best barkeeps in the Columbus area. i enjoy the steaks, the burgers, and the fish and chips. the food is great, and there is plenty there to eat. for dessert, dont forget the fried snickers! Pros: waitstaff, food, choice of drinks Cons: may be a long wait, parking is around bac more
Reply | Report abuse |

I didn't understand the attraction . . . 2/26/2005

This was an hour and ahlf wait in tight quarters to have average bar food. . . the good news is there was no smoking so it didn't stink . . .the menu is primarily ""what would you like deep fried"" . . . .and most food tastes good deep fried . . . I didn't see anything 'special' about the meal of the place . . .I'd eat there for a fast off peek time meal for something average . .but i'd never wait for the experience again!!!!! . .reservations aren't accepted more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Place to Meet Friends 9/4/2003

The fish and chips are the best I've had anyplace. I also like the Canjun Seafood Gumbo and often get that meal since it goes so well with the large beer selection. Speaking of the beer selection. I've eaten here quite a number of times and still have not gone through every beer that they carry. Pros: good food, beer selection, ambience Cons: limited seating more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Fish and Chips 8/18/2002

Worthington Location: Absolute best Fish and Chips in the city, hands down. Great food selection (try the blue cheese potato skins), very good beer selection. No alcohol outside but it's just great to sit on the sidewalk of quaint Worthington and watch the world go by. Plastic chairs / tables aren't the most luxurious but the food makes up for it. Very friendly staff and patrons. Afterward, zip across the street for coffee at Scottie MacBean and ice cream at Graeter's. Pros: Food, Service, location Cons: long wait -peak hours, no alcohol outside, High Street traffic more
Reply | Report abuse |

Feels like home.... 8/12/2002

This pub is a great place to eat, watch TV, relax, and have a few drinks. What more could you want?! more
Reply | Report abuse |

it dowsn't get more comfortable than thi 8/7/2002

comfort foods featuring hearty soups, big sandwiches, great potatoes & much more. if only one person wants the comfort food & you're going with a few, don't worry, the stupendous salads & wings will be sure to please the whole crowd. Pros: menu variety, service Cons: parking, size of dining room more
Reply | Report abuse |

Good Time... 5/31/2002

What a nice place. The location is wonderful..nice shops line the street which is great to help walk off all the fish and chips you just consumed. It is great! I didnt think Fish and Chips could be this good south of the Canadian border or on this side of the pond. I stand corrected. Good food, nice ambience (unless your looking for a romantic setting). My only complaint is that the service was a bit slow. Good time. Pros: Good Food, Nice Location, Good Parking Cons: Slow Service more
Reply | Report abuse |

You'll think you're in England 5/22/2002

Old Bag of Nails is one of the few places to which I will make a point of taking a visitor in Columbus. The atmosphere can's be beat. The location in Worthington is tiny but it exudes an atmosphere that cannot be duplicated anywhere. They have a wonderful selection of domestic and imported beers (I always go with the Samuel Smith's Oatmeal Stout) and their Fish & Chips will make you say ""Blimey!"". Probably the best Pub in town. Pros: Atmosphere, Beer selection more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Old Bag Of Nails Pub


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial

  • The Scene
    Named after the London pub where Paul McCartney met first wife Linda Eastman, each Old Bag is decorated with beer-can collections, bric-a-brac and other pub paraphernalia. The...

  • 2/20/2004 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Mon. - Thu., Sun. 11am - 11pm;Fri. - Sat. 11am - 12pm
  • Payments: American Express, Discover, Master Card, Visa
badge