Mulberry Street

Mulberry Street has good pizza - this coming from a Brooklyn transplant. I moved out here 2 years ago and basically thought we would be camping out in the pizza dept. Mulberry Street is as good as many of our neighborhood pizzerias in Brooklyn were. I order from here all the time and the grandma pies are excellent! Thank you Mulberry Street Pros: nice selection more

Visited Mulberry Street the evening of 12/21/08 with a gift certificate in search of a place to have a family gathering with a nice environment and good food. Food & Service was good. more

There are a few really great Pizzerias around and this is one of them. I can never resist stopping in to grab a slice with my daughter when ... more

My husband and I had dinner on Saturday night, the food and service were great. The waitress was very attentive and friendly. There surron... more

A few years ago I used to visit this place often for their salad pizza. One day I happened to notice something strange on the slice. I showed the gentleman behind the counter, in a discreet manner, that there was a insect on the pizza. At first he denied that this was the case, and tried to pass it off as ""oven residue"". I'm not even sure what that is. After I pointed out the antenna and wings that the ""oven residue"" possessed, he brought over his manager. I showed the manager the insect and he turned to me and said, ""So what do you want me to do about it?"" I didn't know how to answer. Having worked in the restaurant business before, I know that in situations like these a apologetic attitude works much better than a defensive one. All I could say was, just make sure in the future that you wash the lettuce in a more thorough manner. He said he could not prevent situations like these. That secured the fact that I was never to return. He never offered me another slice (I had only taken two bites) or a refund. I didn't bother to ask, he was being completely unprofessional. I don't know if my young face made him feel like he could treat me in that manner, but I've made sure to tell everyone I know who eats there to avoid it in the future.My advice for that manager: be more professional and wash your lettuce! Cons: Food not prepared in a careful and sanitary manner more

A few years ago I used to visit this place often for their salad pizza. One day I happened to notice something strange on the slice. I showed the gentleman behind the counter, in a discreet manner, that there was a insect on the pizza. At first he denied that this was the case, and tried to pass it off as "oven residue". I'm not even sure what that is. After I pointed out the antenna and wings that the "oven residue" possessed, he brought over his manager. I showed the manager the insect and he turned to me and said, "So what do you want me to do about it?" I didn't know how to answer. Having worked in the restaurant business before, I know that in situations like these a apologetic attitude works much better than a defensive one. All I could say was, just make sure in the future that you wash the lettuce in a more thorough manner. He said he could not prevent situations like these. That secured the fact that I was never to return. He never offered me another slice (I had only taken two bites) or a refund. I didn't bother to ask, he was being completely unprofessional. I don't know if my young face made him feel like he could treat me in that manner, but I've made sure to tell everyone I know who eats there to avoid it in the future.My advice for that manager: be more professional and wash your lettuce! Cons: Food not prepared in a careful and sanitary manner more

This pizza and food are both delicous. I order this from Lindenhurst and drive the few extra minutes to pick it up. more

It all starts with great sauce. The chicken parm is awesome. Pastas are cooked right. Meatballs are great but the sausages are a little tough and overcooked but still tasty. They even cook some signature chicken dishes without flour for my wife. Pizza in the front is some of the best on the Island. We go once a month. Pros: Sauce, Pastas, Pizza more

The food here is very good. I would definitely come here again. We attended a rehearsal dinner here. The staff was great and everything was ... more

We enjoyed eating here one weekend afternoon while strolling through Babylon's main street village. The pizza had plentiful varieties, and ... more