La Trattoria Italian Restaurant

Claim
marker

201 N Madison Ave
Greenwood, IN 46142

marker
(317) 859-0487
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:

Restaurants

,

Italian Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

,

European Restaurants

Reviews
( 3 )
( 2 )
( 1 )
( 3 )
( 3 )

Best

I had a steak and it was one of the best steaks I have ever had. Can't say enough about it. The Steak just melted in my mouth. My wife had a pasta dish with portabello mushrooms ...

Worst

We unfortunetly had to wait so long for everything. supposedly out ticket got mixed up. Horrible 1st...

Anniversary no no 11/5/2013

After my husband selected this steak house for our special nite, We had a reservation and still waited... more

Anniversary no no 11/5/2013

ruffruff3 Provided by Partner
After my husband selected this steak house for our special nite, We had a reservation and still waited almost 30 minutes for a table. It was a ver... more

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/21/2012

Needs Anger Management. I Witnessed the proprietor verbally attack a nearby table and threaten physical violence. I'm not sure what the original dispute was over but the patrons affirmed numerous times that they would cover the bill, they stayed seated and kept their voices at a reasonable level. I couldn't hear most of what they said. But the owner stomped around the patio with his chest all puffed up and loomed up over their table repeatedly. All while yelling, cursing and repeatedly threatening his patrons. Plus at least 8 of the staff joined in on the assult. This lasted a good 15 minutes while the group wrapped up their check. When the group went to leave the owner even followed them down the alley.  It RUINED our evening. Unfortunately we had already paid. On the way out I shared with some of the staff that I found it very inappropriate and disruptive.  To which they TURNED on US! Very toxic. I feel sorry for anyone working there and would look into pressing charges if I had been at the table he attacked. Prior to all this the food and service were average at best and it was over priced. NEVER GOING BACK! more

long wait 2/4/2012

We unfortunetly had to wait so long for everything. supposedly out ticket got mixed up. Horrible 1st... more

long wait 2/4/2012

odell Provided by Partner
We unfortunetly had to wait so long for everything. supposedly out ticket got mixed up. Horrible 1st impression. Mgmt. new I was aggrevated, and... more

Worst Italian Rest in Indy! 9/19/2011

Service was awful - waited 35 mins on our appetizer, needed drink refills throughout the 1hr 1/2 we were there and waited another 35 mins for the server to check on us after our main course came out. Food was full of garlic powder and tasted like it had been frozen. Servers were wearing Colts jerseys and baggy pants (their underwear was showing when they would clean a table. The owner didn more

La Trattoria in Greenwood, In 12/30/2010

Wonderful evening with Portabello mushrooms and filet mignon. Service was very good and the place was packed. We shall return for a second sampling very soon. I recommend this establishment for a nice evening out for dinner. more

best steak ever 3/30/2010

I had a steak and it was one of the best steaks I have ever had. Can't say enough about it. The Steak just melted in my mouth. My wife had a pasta dish with portabello mushrooms and it was also wonderful. I recommend this place to anyone and everyone. Pros: steaks more

Not impressed anymore 8/7/2009

La Trattoria used to be one of the greatest little places in Greenwood where you could dine in or outdoors and get one of the best steaks in town. Never have been impressed with their italian, but the steak used to be outstanding. Since their re-open, my husband and I have gone three times now, and all three times - steak was not cooked right, they clearly only use frozen bread (I asked for some with no butter) and the service seems more friendly only to the frequent visitors. It's a shame becuase we really enjoyed this place. It still has a great portabella mushroom appetizer and the location is nice, but we will be waiting quite a while to try it again. Pros: outdoor seating Cons: food quality more

Save your money, even Olive Garden is better. 10/22/2008

I was not impressed with this place at all. After driving by it and seeing how cute it looked at the time (the old building has since burned down and is being rebuilt at the time of this posting), my boyfriend and I decided to stop and eat there one evening. It always looked pretty crowded, so we thought it must have been a pretty decent restaurant. I paid $16 (!!) for ravioli and I could only eat half of it, I was really hungry too. It was tasteless and so poorly drained the water from the pasta diluted the sauce. There were puddles of water on my place. I don't remember what my boyfriend ordered, but he was not blown away either, and his entree was not cheap. Maybe it was just an off night for them, but after leaving with empty pockets and empty stomachs, we weren't going to risk going back there again to give them a second chance. We make the drive downtown to Iaria's if we want good, affordable, Italian. Pros: Used to be in a cute old building, not sure what it looks like now Cons: Food, pricing more

Best Filet (better than Ruth's Chris!!) 10/13/2008

My husband and I went on many dates to La Trattoria and enjoyed every moment. The staff is friendly and inviting! The food is delicious and perfect! We don't live in the area anymore, but when we visit family, we make sure we always go here while we are in town! I was sad to hear they had a fire at the restuarant and hope it is repaired by now! It is a great little restaurant for the town on Greenwood and I hope it is always there for many years to come! Pros: Food, staff, decor Cons: parking, need more:) more

Best food in greenwood! 12/13/2007

Im new to the area and super picky about my food especially my steaks. La Trattoria it yet to disapoint me. It is a great hole in the wall yet romantic atmosphere will wonderful service, great wine and amazing filet mingon! I have been there probably a dozen times and every visit has been more than wonderful! If you have no tried it you need to! There stuffed portabello mushroom is to die for and the filet is a much have! It is a great place to take a date as well! I will continue to frequent there! Pros: Wonderful food and cozy atmosphere! Cons: yet to find a con! more
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for La Trattoria Italian Restaurant


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
badge