Italian Pie Shoppe

Italian pie shoppe on Grand Avenue: This place is a cozy pizzeria, but it hasn't been remodeled for about 30 years. First time I had the deep dish pizza, it was great. The second visit I was utterly disappointed with the thin crust--soggy, burned at the edges, and it was cut into very tiny squares--very odd. On both visits, the servers were so busy that they could barely even keep up with our table. No time for personality. You'll also be eating on plastic plates with dinky silverware. The pasta and pizza are served on these beat-up, old, scratched aluminum pans. Freshen the place up, buy some plates, and hire a busboy to help the servers and this place will be much better. Pros: deep dish pizza, casual, live organ music Cons: thin crust pizza, too casual, servers need support more

I have been going to Italian Pie Shoppe for over 10 years and have never had anything but excellent food! They have the best sauce in town! I highly recommend! more

....into the wooden booth, but the food makes up for! The specials which include salad, bread, and pasta are excellent choices for the price. Baked mostaccioli with a meat ball was around $6 and you have leftovers. The Italian Fry Appetizer was good as well. Group had calzones and pizza - everyone enjoyed their food and I'm waiting to go back. We were there at 1:15, so they service and parking were fine. Pros: Portions, Price Cons: Parking more

We ordered, it took a long time, something weird with the order, but the pizza was good. The service was good, and they gave us our beer free because it took so long! Pros: Kid Friendly, Handicap Accessible, Cozy Cons: Not cheap, Pizza takes a while more

This is a typical small town pizzaria. The food was good, the service is excellent, they make you feel like family when eating there. Give it try, it's worth the effort. Pros: Great service, Nice area for a walk Cons: The pizza is average, Ambience is lacking more

i can't get enough of the thin crust pizza - perfection! Pros: good value Cons: limited parking, service can be slow more