top 10

Goodfella's Catering

Claim
marker

1718 Hylan Blvd (at Seaview Ave & Garretson)
Staten Island, NY 10305

marker
(718) 987-2422
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Reviews
( 11 )
( 4 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

Vodka pie and calamari

Worst

All reviews seem positive

Vodka pie and calamari 11/20/2011

Vodka pie and calamari more
Reply | Report abuse |

I will be Back for sure!! 12/12/2010

Very good pizzas me and my friends enjoy them a lot specially when we asked the waitress if we can have a special pie, she told us that and I quote "" Our pizza men here will make you anything you want "" so we have a vegetable pie and we add fontina cheese ,provolone, white onions and fresh tomato the pie was amazing the pizza man cooked the pie perfect personally I taste every single vegetable and cheeses, The Vodka pie was good too ,,so I will be eating there again very soon !!!! more
Reply | Report abuse |

worlds best pizza 12/12/2010

If you love pizza you have to go to this place. Its a great restaurant and bar that serves real brick oven pizza. The smoking goodfella is absolutly incredible fresh smoked mozzarella roasted pepper cream sauce wood fired peppers sausage basil romano! Also try the vodka pie this is where it was created the best vodka pie ever! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Pizza I've ever had! 12/12/2010

Their old world pie is definitely the best pizza I've ever had -- totally distinct from any other pizza! I came from Jersey and took all kinds of public transport just to get there -- and it was totally worth it! The food is delicious and I wouldn't change anything about it or wish any part of it was better -- it's totally perfect and the service is awesome! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best restaurant on the island for pizza and pasta 12/7/2010

I love this place. Wood fired pizza's and fresh mozzarella. UMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!! These guys know how to do pizza the right way. They just opened up a full service bar too! more
Reply | Report abuse |

incredible pizza 11/19/2008

adrewscudera Provided by Partner
this has to be by far the best tasting pizza i have ever had. They use fresh mozzarella and a real wood burning brick oven with a large selection ... more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Damn Pizza on Staten Island. period. 6/20/2005

This pizza is one of the best on Staten Island. From the first bite, right down to the last. Anyway you slice it, with whatever toppings. Their pizza is the best more
Reply | Report abuse |

This is the BEST brick oven pizza 5/12/2004

This is the best Pizza you could ever imagine with fresh ingredients and a nice crispy crust. The staff is friendly and you feel like part of the family when you go there. I now live in Virginia but still go there to get pizaa. Its true! Pros: Pizza, Pizza, Pizza more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great pizza 1/31/2004

definitly the best pizza on the island...vodka pizza is awesome and calamari was good too! more
Reply | Report abuse |

One of a kind Pizza 12/14/2002

Like no other pizza is Goodfella's Brick Oven. I remember when they opened in the mid 90's here at this first Staten Island location, I did want to go simply because of the obvious mafioso connotation within the name of the restaurant. Once I tasted the food, I was their biggest fan. Goodfella's made me try things I would have never considered tasting, simply because whatever they make is delicious. Goodfella's continuity has earned my loyalty. Pros: quatro cantone pie, mozzerella in carozza, free drink when wait Cons: calzone, long waits more
Reply | Report abuse |

The best pizza! 10/6/2002

This place hasn't been voted the country's best pizza for nothing! Their Pizza alla Vodka is the BEST! more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Goodfella's Catering


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

Goodfella's Catering, Staten Island's Finest Italian Catering

Owner Message

  • Goodfella's Old World Restaurant & Bar is well known for its many accolades, including World's Best Pizza from 2007-2010. Bring that world famous food into your home or office. Goodfella's will cater any size party and will come complete with sternos, racks, pans, napkins, utensils, bread, garden salad and FREE local delivery! Goodfella's Catering has an extensive and mouth-watering menu of Appetizers & Salads; Pasta; Chicken, Veal, Sausage, and Eggplant entrees; Seafood; 3 & 6 Foot Heroes, and Desserts. Custom menu also available; Goodfella's will accommodate any special needs. Goodfella's specializes in corporate events and corporate parties in Staten Island and at your Manhattan office. Goodfella's has the finest Italian catering in Staten Island and is perfect for birthday parties, holiday parties, Superbowl parties.

Additional information
  • Hours: Sun-Thurs 11:30am-11pm; Fri-Sat 11:30am-2am
  • Payments: Master Card, Visa, American Express, Discover
  • Neighborhoods: South Beach / Old Town
badge