top 10

Goodfella's Catering

Claim
marker

1718 Hylan Blvd (at Seaview Ave & Garretson)
Staten Island, NY 10305

marker
(718) 987-2422
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Goodfella's Catering - Staten Island, NY
Reviews
( 11 )
( 4 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

Vodka pie and calamari

Worst

All reviews seem positive

GREAT PLACE 8/6/2007

I LOVE THE PIZZA I GUEST THAT WHY THEY WHERE VOTED WORLD BEST PIZZA. OH YES AND GREAT STEAKS COOKED IN THE WOOD FIRED OVENS more
Reply | Report abuse |
No image

Goodfellas 5/6/2006

Goodfellas is great. The pizza's crust is impeccable and they cook it in an authentic brick oven, which makes it even better. The service is good, and so are the prices! Their pizza has won awards, and that's for a reason! This place is much better than Denino's (which people rave about, I have no clue why!) more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Pizza! 8/31/2005

My family loves the pizza alla vodka! We've tried some of the other selections, but weren't thrilled with them. The pizza alla vodka is the sole reason we patron this restaurant! Fried calamari & ravioli are also pretty good. Staff is courteous, but not particularly impressive. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Pizzeria/Restaurant 8/31/2005

Goodfellas has great pizza and italian food. my husband and i like to take people out to this restaurant when they visit from out of town. it has good italian food for great prices. the service is usually very good as well. there is not usually a wait and you dont need reservations. the pizza is award winning so i highly recommend it more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Goodfella's Catering


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

Goodfella's Catering, Staten Island's Finest Italian Catering

Owner Message

  • Goodfella's Old World Restaurant & Bar is well known for its many accolades, including World's Best Pizza from 2007-2010. Bring that world famous food into your home or office. Goodfella's will cater any size party and will come complete with sternos, racks, pans, napkins, utensils, bread, garden salad and FREE local delivery! Goodfella's Catering has an extensive and mouth-watering menu of Appetizers & Salads; Pasta; Chicken, Veal, Sausage, and Eggplant entrees; Seafood; 3 & 6 Foot Heroes, and Desserts. Custom menu also available; Goodfella's will accommodate any special needs. Goodfella's specializes in corporate events and corporate parties in Staten Island and at your Manhattan office. Goodfella's has the finest Italian catering in Staten Island and is perfect for birthday parties, holiday parties, Superbowl parties.

Additional information
  • Hours: Sun-Thurs 11:30am-11pm; Fri-Sat 11:30am-2am
  • Payments: Master Card, Visa, American Express, Discover
  • Neighborhoods: South Beach / Old Town
badge