top 10

Eagles Pizza

Claim
marker

2 N High St
New Albany, OH 43054

marker
(614) 855-2231
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 5 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

We have tried many pizza's all around The Columbus area. If we could eat only one, it would be Villa Eagles Pizza. We bought a pizza delivery bag just to carry it all the way home...

Worst

This pizza used to be good. I bought a pizza there recently and it was terrible. I don't know if they went thru an owner change or what. The sauce tasted like stale paste with ...

Editorial review from Citysearch 10/29/2012

The best pizza and sandwiches in town! more
Reply | Report abuse |

We choose Eagles Pizza! 2/12/2009

We have tried many pizza's all around The Columbus area. If we could eat only one, it would be Villa Eagles Pizza. We bought a pizza delivery bag just to carry it all the way home hot. There is p/u only, NO DELIVERY. They have a dining room, but not Large(seats about 35). You order at the counter, and they bring your drinks and food to you. They do not take credit or debit cards, but provide an ATM. They operate on cash and checks (for locals). Pros: Low prices, great taste Cons: No delivery more
Reply | Report abuse |

Terrible Pizza - Sauce is bad 1/20/2009

This pizza used to be good. I bought a pizza there recently and it was terrible. I don't know if they went thru an owner change or what. The sauce tasted like stale paste with no flavor at all. The incredients were sub-par at best. I actually threw over half the pizza away. I have eaten pizza all over the USA and have to say this is some of the worst I have tasted in Columbus. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Of the hook 8/13/2002

This pizza is the best that I have tasted. The environment is very friendly as well. Pros: Inexpensive, Friendly people, quick more
Reply | Report abuse |

Eagles Pizza ROCKS 8/8/2002

I am from Steubenvill, home of valley pizza. When I moved here I thought I would never find pizza as good as it is in the valley, until I found Eagles. I love that place! I moved to New Albany so I could be close to them! more
Reply | Report abuse |

EaglesPizzaRocks 7/23/2002

Beats Donatos in taste and costs half as much, a large pepperoni is only $7.00 more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Eagles Pizza


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Additional information
  • Hours: Sun 4pm-10pm, Mon-Thu 10:30am-10pm, Fri-Sat 10:30am-11pm
badge