David Reynolds Jewelry & Coins

Claim
marker

4009 Central Ave
St. Petersburg, FL 33713

marker
(727) 327-2646
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
David Reynolds Jewelry & Coins - St. Petersburg, FL
David Reynolds Jewelry & Coins - St. Petersburg, FL
David Reynolds Jewelry & Coins - St. Petersburg, FL
David Reynolds Jewelry & Coins - St. Petersburg, FL
Reviews
( 7 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 2 )

Best

Shane the custom jewelry designer is the best in the land. VERY pleasant to work with & very knowledgeable. I have had several custom pieces made, I get compliments all the time a...

Worst

Horrifying experience. Bought a custom $600 dollar ring. It was supposed to be a recreation of a ring I had lost. The ring I received was all wrong. The jeweler was extremely rude...

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/21/2013

We gave the information on what we wanted to Shane he developed the ring and it is one of a kind and everything my wife and I wanted. Thank you Shane and David Reynolds! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/21/2013

I have been a graduate gemologist for more years than I care to state I grew up in the business and worked for the first GIA graduate for years. I have taught gemology in Tampa since 1982. Further, in the years I taught, Shane was the only one I ever proctored who ever totally aced the GIA exams. I would trust him with anything I own..I recommend him to anyone who asks me. He is a gentleman, he is honest and he is one really fantastic designer. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/21/2013

The quality of Shane's work is amazing.I wish I had his talent. Any thing that has to do with jewelry, Shane at David Reynolds Jewelry is the person to talk to.He will not disappoint you.He has never let me down. He is awesome !!! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/21/2013

I have trusted my antique wedding band to Shane at David Reynolds Jewelry, when I lost a very small diamond. The ring came back perfect, polished, and looking better than when I received it 25 years ago. As the Executive Director of the Florida Society of Goldsmiths, I know a large number of jeweler. Shane has been helpful when I have questions about techniques and does stunning work. My friends and I are excited that he chose to purchase the shop, because we would have followed him anywhere. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/20/2013

\r \r Mark, I understand that you are very upset with us and on a KILL DAVID REYNOLDS campaign. If your frustration is really based on thinking that we damaged your stone, we didn't. We spoke with your appraiser and even she told you that it's not likely that we caused the damage. \r \r Yes I'm Shane Socash G.G. (GIA) the new owner. I have been an employee of David Reynolds for 14 years and now the founder Earl Waters works here (for me:) 40 hours a week as a mentor, a business advisor, and a friend. Things are very much the same as they've always been.\r \r Ultimately Mark, you were dismissed as a customer not because of this one accusation, but because of a history since 2006 (as far back as our computer records go) of you creating a stink and then looking for some kind of financial adjustment. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/20/2013

I have been a dealer in Pinellas County for 33 years. I have taken the GIA diamond grading course . Do not ever take a stone here to be mounted . If they make a mistake they will not own up to it and it will be a costly mistake for you . The owner seems nice when they take your money , but have a problem and good luck . They keep a record of any complaints you make and will use it against you and tell you "" you are fired as a customer "" . I am flabergasted how they treated me . No one I have ever dealt with in 33 years , has ever been so rude to me .\r Shane is nothing like the original owners Ron & Earl. When a GIA diamond appraiser who knows my stone said they might have fractured it , Shane refused to even look at it for me .\r I would never treat my customers with such disrespect .BEWARE ! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/8/2013

I LOVE David Reynolds Jewelry and I recommend them to all my friends. I was a customer when Ronnie and Earl owed the place and think that Shane is doing a wonderful job of keeping up the store’s excellent reputation. The store has a great selection of jewelry and their repair work is amazing. I have a necklace that my mother gave to me years ago and the clasp broke. When I picked up the necklace, I expected it to have just a new clasp - they polished and cleaned it so that it looked brand new! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/5/2013

I have been a customer at David Reynolds for the last 5 or so years, (mostly for coins and bullion but also for some jewelry repairs.) I have found the staff to be courteous, helpful, and very knowledgeable. I have tried some of the other stores in Tampa Bay and David Reynold's prices are consistently the most competitive. \r more
Reply | Report abuse |

Editorial review from Citysearch 6/12/2013

I have dealt with david reynolds a few times and its obvious they try to gauge your knowledge for exploitation instead of being fair to all customers...its a glorified pawn shop...very inconsistent, one guy will tell you one thing and the other gay will tell you something else ...unless you are over the age of 50 or an obvious member of the gay community these guys will try to rob you blind...if you are between the ages of 18 and 40 they treat you like you are a thief the moment you walk thru the door....if you are shopping any jewelry/coins go to international diamond center...which is head and shoulders better in every way than david Reynolds...no comparison...its not even an opinion its a fact...I urge u to see for yourself....if u must deal with david Reynolds ask for Shane. more
Reply | Report abuse |

BestJewelers & Custom Work Anywhere 2/13/2012

Shane the custom jewelry designer is the best in the land. VERY pleasant to work with & very knowledgeable. I have had several custom pieces made, I get compliments all the time and tell people where they came from. We would not trust anyone else. We have purchased other items as well and been treated very well by the owners and staff. We love the family friendly feeling of David Reynold's Jewelers, we tell all our friends and now you. Get in there to see them you certiany will not be dissapointed more
Reply | Report abuse |

The Best and Fair Jewelry & Coins Store by Far 11/17/2011

Best Experience!!! Run, Don't Walk or you'll miss out!!! I have the best experience at David Reynold's. The staff and Jewelers are so knowledgeable and helpful. They have the best price in town and are well known to be the fairest by far in prices to buy from and sell to. Their quality of workmenships on custom jewelers or repairs are superb. I do not hesitate to refer any of my friends and family to David Reynold's because I am so confident that they will be taken care of. I have been in customer service industry for many years and have trained people in customer care, they have earned 10 out of 10 rating from me. Thank you sooooo much for my fine jewelers and especially my amazing wedding ring that the Jewelers have design specifically for my taste. David Reynold's will have my business and everyone that I encounter. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Horrible Experience! Stay clear of this place!!!!!!!!!!!! 11/7/2011

Horrifying experience. Bought a custom $600 dollar ring. It was supposed to be a recreation of a ring I had lost. The ring I received was all wrong. The jeweler was extremely rude and unwilling to fix the mistakes he had made. So I was forced to take the ring that was not made to the specifications I had ordered. As if that wasn't enough the stone on my ring cracked the second day I wore it. So I took the ring back in to the store, thinking that they would of course replace the faulty stone for free, they pretty much laughed in my face and told me was my fault and that I would have to pay another $120 to replace the stone. So then I would've been $720 out and who knows if the new stone would break again. Now all I'm left with is a $600 whole in my bank account and a broken ring. Don't waste your money! Find a different jeweler. WORST EXPERIENCE EVER!!!!!! EXTREMELY RUDE SCAM ARTISTS!!!!!!!! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best in Jewelry and coins 12/16/2010

Great service, excellent prices and a very knowledgeable staff. Definitely the place to go for that special person in your life. more
Reply | Report abuse |

The Place to go for Custom Jewelry 12/14/2010

If you want custom jewelry this is the place to go. The Jeweler is talented and knowledgeable, and will work with you to get that perfect piece that is you. Customer service is terrific, whether you are selling gold, buying coins or a special piece of jewelry their prices are unbeatable. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Honest and Helpful 10/21/2010

Today I sold some gold coins at David Reynold's, and I was extremely pleased with my experience. I called many local stores, and they offered me by far they best price. Over the phone and in person, I was treated in a friendly and professional way. They delivered exactly what they said they would with no muss or fuss. They also consulted with me about an altering a ring, and took the time to make measurements and offer their best recommendations. Will definitely do business again -- I just found my jeweler. more
Reply | Report abuse |

St. Petersburg's Finest Jewelry Store 5/19/2009

The Gemologist / jeweler on staff was incredibly knowledgeable. He helped to educate my fiance on the finer points of choosing a diamond for a beautiful custom made (at David Reynolds) engagement ring. I couldn't be happier:) Pros: Ethical, Friendly & Knowledgeable Staff Cons: busy store more
Reply | Report abuse |

THE BEST IN PINELLAS COUNTY 1/20/2008

Wonderful staff makes each individual feel special and the personable one on one service is superior.\r The inventory is magnificient like no other in town and many one of a kind unique selections to choose from. Go see for yourself and I'm sure you will agree. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Poor customer service 10/10/2007

I thought they were very rude... I was not helped at all. Inconvenient location. Not enough parking. Poor selection and I can better prices on line... How can you do business this way? more
Reply | Report abuse |

5-star Service 2/5/2007

A wonderful bunch of people to do business with. Great attitudes, ethical and very professional. I refer their company to everyone. I always leave there with a smile and great product. Pros: Ambience, Service, Professional, Pleasant attitudes Cons: Parking more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Additional information
  • Hours: Mon - Fri, 9am - 5pm; Sat, 10am - 2pm; Sun, closed
  • Payments: Discover, Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods: United Central, Bayview
badge