Carl's Steaks

Claim
marker

508 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10016

marker
(212) 696-5336
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews
( 15 )
( 8 )
( 3 )
( 5 )
( 6 )

Best

Carl's steaks are amazing. I am not even big on red meat or beef in general, and after I tried their cheese steak a year ago, I am ADDICTED. It is like a drug, and I often crave i...

Worst

After placing a delivery order, waiting an hour, calling to check the status, a staff member literally barked at me that the order had left and hung up on me. The food is good ...

Meh 2/3/2005

Not even close to Philly cheesesteaks! They aren't horrible, but they let the meat sit too long and it congeals. My main issue is that they are WAY too salty. The bread is good, though. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here unless I were hungover and needed greasy food. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Not the real thing 12/28/2004

While Carl's sandwiches may look like a Philly cheesesteak, nothing about it tastes anything like one except for maybe the bread. The meat is subpar and dry, the onions are too large and overcooked, and they are skimpy on the cheese wiz. I say, if you want a real cheesesteak, then head to Philly. more
Reply | Report abuse |

NOT better then Philly. 12/28/2004

Carl's makes a decent steak sandwich. Nothing to write home about. Steve in Tudor is high to say it's better then Philly. The meat is too dry, they have a huge pile of meat on the grill and wedge you off a slab when you order. It's been sitting there all day though, it kinda looses it's umph. Overall I like the place, it's too small, so all steak shops are. For sure the best in New York, but that ain't saying much. Pros: Decent Sandwich, good fries, free refills Cons: , could be cheaper, a little dry more
Reply | Report abuse |

Better Than Philly 11/29/2004

We've got it better than Philly. Our NYC Carl's is better than can be found in Philadelphia--plus, our's is friendly and helpful. Delivery service great. I've lived in Philly and Wash, DC (where there are some cheesesteak outposts), nothing beats what Carl's offers right here in NYC. Want to get the first-rate, real experience: get ""The Works"" with ""Whiz"" and Mayo w/ extra S&P. >>Signed, Steve in Tudor City Pros: Cheezie-Oozie, Quality, They try harder more
Reply | Report abuse |

Greasy & Good 9/14/2004

I've never had an authentic philly cheesesteak from philly, but I've had some bad cheesesteaks. The sandwiches here are pretty good; if you like cheesesteaks, I think you'll like these - greasy, lots of stringy meat with cheese and onions, on a good soft bun. The only thing I wish for is a little more distribution of the cheesewiz. As people mentioned, seating is tight - there's 2 tables only and a standing room only counter. The cheese steak itself is about $6.50. Afterwards, you feel pretty heavy, but that's what greasy food does to you. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Philly Steaks in NYC!!! 8/19/2004

I grew up in Philly and consider myself an expert on the Philly cheesesteak. I've studied intensively at Pat's, Geno's and Jim's in Philadelphia (the 3 homes to the greatest cheesesteaks in the world). Carl's is right there with them. The key is the roll and they've nailed it. The steak, onions and mushrooms are excellent as well. I recommend putting the wiz on top of the steak as opposed to below as Carl's does but it's great none the less. Little room to eat it but the service is energetic and quick. Highly recommended. Pros: Authenticity, Food, Service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Cheesesteak 8/9/2004

Well, I have been to Pat's Steaks in Philly more than once (considered by many to be the best cheesesteak place in town), and Carl's Steaks are just as good! The bread is fresh, onions tasty, and the meat is juicy. The only downside is there really aren't enough seats to accomodate the customers. What will happen when this place really catches on? I made a special trip from Long Island and it was well worth it! Pros: Tasty, Fresh Cons: , Pricey more
Reply | Report abuse |

mmm..good! 7/17/2004

Best place to get something to eat that is filling after you have spent all your money drinking! The steaks arrive fast and hot! Service is fast and employees are very cool cats! You may even meet some girls that actually like to eat! Strong recommendation! Cheers to the friendly and speedy staff! Pros: inexpensive, speedy, cool employees Cons: , drunk idiots more
Reply | Report abuse |

Nothing Special 6/25/2004

I dont know how this place claims to have the best cheese steaks in NYC, I'd say they're average at best. When I think of a cheesesteak I want a big, sloppy, cheesy sandwich, which isn't what you get. However the bread is real fresh. Come on Carl, step it up a notch. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Philly Cheese Steaks in Town 5/31/2004

I have become an addict of the Carl's Philly Cheese Steak. I never thought that Cheese Whiz, Steak and Onions could taste so good. The bread is perfect and while many people are turned off by the idea of Cheese Whiz on anything, I will say ""Don't knock it 'til you try it."" Wherever Carl is and whoever he is, I shake his hand in the creation of the perfect lunch/dinner. Simply terrific! Pros: Taste, Price, Preparation Cons: , Crowded during lunch more
Reply | Report abuse |

Finally Philly CheeseSteaks Back In NYC 4/5/2004

Service is very friendly and organized. Not too many places to eat in (a few stools and small tables) so I had mine to go. Got a cheesteak with the onions and wiz. Tastes great and the preparation is authentic also (Steak is chopped). Meat is tender and tasty. Very good value also as the sandwich is pretty good size and they do not skimp on the meat! I am so happy that NYC finally has some good cheesesteaks to sink their teeth into! Pros: Cheap, Good size, Authentic more
Reply | Report abuse |

It's not Pat's or Geno's, but... 2/26/2004

Honestly, it's as close as you're going to get to a decent cheesesteak in this town. Pros: Cheezewhiz more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Place! 2/23/2004

Had a very enjoyable experience at Carl's. Taste like Philadelphia to me!!! Quick service and super tastey food. I like the Cheez Whiz w/ onions. The full sandwiches are kinda big so I would recommend splitting one if you go with someone. You can always order another one. Seating is limited so be aware. And there is no bathroom but they do provide plenty of moist towelettes. Pros: Delicious!!, Inexpensive more
Reply | Report abuse |

Unfortunate Experience 1/22/2004

This one goes out to Carl... Upon entering the establishment today for lunch, I accepted the 20 minute wait I was warned of. However, after 30 minutes of waiting and then observing people who arrived after I did happily eating hot cheesesteaks is unacceptable. I kindly asked one of the workers behind the counter if my order was coming up soon. As I suspected, my simple order had somehow been pushed to the end of the line and not yet started. After 45 minutes of waiting, the least Carl's could do is not take your money before giving you your food so you have the option of walking out in anger with nothing lost but 45 minutes of your life. Pros: nothing Cons: service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Finally 10/4/2003

Finally in NYC there is a restaurant that serves the true Philly cheesesteak. Not only are the cheesesteaks fantastic, but the service is quick and friendly. As a wise friend said as we left, ""the smell was so good that I could eat another one""... more
Reply | Report abuse |

about time 10/2/2003

NYC finally has a solid cheesesteak (B&B is good but not the real thing). Carl's does its best to crank them out in the traditional Philly style, with soft rolls, cheese whiz and onions. Pros: inexpensive, good for quick lunch Cons: ordering needs work more
Reply | Report abuse |

Not bad... 10/2/2003

Having grown up in Philly and averaged eating 1 cheesesteak per week for 15 years, I was hesitant to try an NYC version. Carl's was surprisingly good however and I recommend it to anyone looking for a decent cheesesteak. The meat could be a little less oily as it drenched the roll, but the roll was nice and soft as it should be. I give it an 8.5 out of 10 with potential. more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Menu for Carl's Steaks


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial

  • In Short
    Owner Carl Provenzano opened this Murray Hill spot to fill a long-standing culinary gap: cheesesteaks. And while Carl's does the famed Philly version, with chopped beef, onions...

  • 9/16/2004 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Monday 11:00 AM - 11:45 PM Tuesday 11:00 AM - 11:45 PM Wednesday 11:00 AM - 11:45 PM Thursday 11:00 AM - 12:45 AM Friday 11:00 AM - 4:00 AM Saturday 11:00 AM - 4:00 AM Sunday 11:00 AM - 10:45 PM
  • Payments: American Express, Visa, Master Card, Discover
  • Neighborhoods: Kips Bay, Midtown, Murray Hill
badge