Here's the skinny on this outfit. First, my AC wasn't getting it done upstairs, so I picked these folks out of the yellow pages because they were local.
After poking around in the attic, they said I needed a new blower. The system was already 15 years old, but I'd only been in the house two years. $750 for the new blower.
AFTER they replace the motor, they go out and check the charge and found it low, so they filled that and said it would cost another pile of money to come back another day and check for leaks. I asked over and over why they didn't just check for a leak in the first place, since it seemed to me that the old blower was still blowing; it's just that the air was hot (this was summer).
Matthews himself came over and gave me some unintelligible technical song and dance why the motor had to be replaced ANYWAY, despite the charge being low. When Matthews added up the ticket, the writing was illegible. After I paid him and he left, I deciphered it all out and saw that Bud had actually short-changed himself because he had added incorrectly. Several months later, I called to remind them that they hadn't charged my credit card at all! Of course, they were glad I called.
The next summer (2010), the whole system stopped working. We called Matthews again to see what the deal was THIS time. He came out and said we needed another expensive part on the outside unit or we could replace the whole system. He charged us $100+ bucks for a ""service charge"" for this bit of advice.
When I asked him why this wasn't brought up as an option the previous year, when he was replacing the blower motor, he said that he would give me a ""deal"" on a new system, given the amount I had spent on the blower. By his own admission, he had told the previous owner of our house four years earlier that the system needed replacing then.
HIS ESTIMATE FOR THE NEW SYSTEM WAS $2000 DOLLARS ABOVE WHAT WE GOT FROM A COUPLE OF OTHER COMPANIES, AND THIS FOR A SYSTEM THAT EVENTUALLY COST US AROUND 5K.
Needless to say, we had the system replaced by someone else. They did a great job and a reasonable price.
more