Agatha's Mystery Theatre

Claim
marker

161 Peachtree Center Ave
Atlanta, GA 30303

marker
(404) 584-2255
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Reviews
( 14 )
( 12 )
( 6 )
( 2 )
( 14 )

Best

We've all been there, trying to find some fun social activity that means NOT hanging out in a bar. Agatha's is the place to go! Reserve your seats and be prepared to enjoy delici...

Worst

This was not at all what i expected. I expected a mystery, however, it was a musical spoof. The 2 actors were entertaining, however, all guests have a speaking part that isn't op...

fun and unique experience 3/11/2003

If you want a fun night out, then check out Agatha's...people that don't have a good time must be negative no matter where they go. The food isn't 4-star, but it's not bad considering you get 5 courses for only $45 a person, and UNLIMITED wine. Most people are hammered by the 2nd or 3rd act, which just adds to the amusement of the whole thing. The show was well writen and the actors were great. Not for the shy, cause you DO have lines to say, so just ham it up, get a refill on that wine, and have a good time... Pros: entertaining, good deal, unique experience more
Reply | Report abuse |

fun and unique experience 3/11/2003

If you want a fun night out, then check out Agatha's...people that don't have a good time must be negative no matter where they go. The food isn't 4-star, but it's not bad considering you get 5 courses for only $45 a person, and UNLIMITED wine. Most people are hammered by the 2nd or 3rd act, which just adds to the amusement of the whole thing. The show was well writen and the actors were great. Not for the shy, cause you DO have lines to say, so just ham it up, get a refill on that wine, and have a good time... Pros: entertaining, good deal, unique experience more
Reply | Report abuse |

Mesmerizing and mysterious and magical 2/6/2003

Always entertaining - great writing and acting. Acoustics sometimes poor, but willing to overlook that for the engaging presence of the actors and their plum roles. Never had a bad time at Agatha's. Pros: entertaining, energetic, engaging more
Reply | Report abuse |

Mesmerizing and mysterious and magical 2/6/2003

Always entertaining - great writing and acting. Acoustics sometimes poor, but willing to overlook that for the engaging presence of the actors and their plum roles. Never had a bad time at Pros: entertaining, energetic, engaging more
Reply | Report abuse |

It Sinks! 1/2/2003

Dont waste your time and money. The place is very small and is setup in a school cafeteria style. The people, not actors, walk up and down the only open row. I guess that to keep you from walking out on the show. It was awful. If you are hungry, do expect much from here. Want a refill, well forget it! It aint gonna happen! Pros: Clean bathrooms Cons: Bad food, Bad Service, Bad Acting more
Reply | Report abuse |

It Sinks! 1/2/2003

Dont waste your time and money. The place is very small and is setup in a school cafeteria style. The people, not actors, walk up and down the only open row. I guess that to keep you from walking out on the show. It was awful. If you are hungry, do expect much from here. Want a refill, well forget it! It aint gonna happen! Pros: Clean bathrooms Cons: Bad food, Bad Service, Bad Acting more
Reply | Report abuse |

The real mystery is.... 12/28/2002

How does Agatha's stay in business? This place stinks! There is no attention paid to decor, service or the PAYING customer. I understand why gratuity is included beforehand...because I certainly wouldn't tip after. My waitress actually asked me to go get my own dinner beverage from the bar. If I have to do the waitstaff's job, I want to be on payroll or get a refund. The show was corny but cute. But it started late and reeeaalllly dragged out to make it seem longer. The food is horrible. If you want dinner theater, go somewhere else and leave it to professionals. If you like to be abused at real theater, you're better off going to the Clermont Lounge. Pros: Good Coffee, It ended, waitress' other job Cons: I went, I stayed, I ate there more
Reply | Report abuse |

The real mystery is.... 12/28/2002

How does Agatha's stay in business? This place stinks! There is no attention paid to decor, service or the PAYING customer. I understand why gratuity is included beforehand...because I certainly wouldn't tip after. My waitress actually asked me to go get my own dinner beverage from the bar. If I have to do the waitstaff's job, I want to be on payroll or get a refund. The show was corny but cute. But it started late and reeeaalllly dragged out to make it seem longer. The food is horrible. If you want dinner theater, go somewhere else and leave it to professionals. If you like to be abused at real theater, you're better off going to the Clermont Lounge. Pros: Good Coffee, It ended, waitress' other job Cons: I went, I stayed, I ate there more
Reply | Report abuse |

Dont waste your money! 9/14/2002

Not a real show, just 2 people that make the paying customers do all the work. The food was awful and the service was very bad. I could not enjoy anything becuase I had lines to read. We went there after reviewing this site and others. I fell it is my duty to warn people about this place. If you want to go to a place with bad food, bad service and corny actors, then this is the place. I was not impressed. Cons: fee parking, crowded seating, bad service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Dont waste your money! 9/14/2002

Not a real show, just 2 people that make the paying customers do all the work. The food was awful and the service was very bad. I could not enjoy anything becuase I had lines to read. We went there after reviewing this site and others. I fell it is my duty to warn people about this place. If you want to go to a place with bad food, bad service and corny actors, then this is the place. I was not impressed. Cons: fee parking, crowded seating, bad service more
Reply | Report abuse |

BAD WAITSTAFF AND FOOD 6/27/2002

Since the waiters aren't working for tips, they seem to feel that they don't have to be courteous. I was seated at a table facing the wall and when I turned my seat around my feet were in the aisle impeding the actors. When I asked for another seat, the waitress said she had no others and offered me a complimentary drink to appease me, which she never gave me. We ended up having a standoff over the drink, the food was bad (do not order the salmon), and the show was pretty long and corny. However, the actress that played Barney Fife was dead on. Cons: Rude waitstaff, Bad food more
Reply | Report abuse |

BAD WAITSTAFF AND FOOD 6/27/2002

Since the waiters aren't working for tips, they seem to feel that they don't have to be courteous. I was seated at a table facing the wall and when I turned my seat around my feet were in the aisle impeding the actors. When I asked for another seat, the waitress said she had no others and offered me a complimentary drink to appease me, which she never gave me. We ended up having a standoff over the drink, the food was bad (do not order the salmon), and the show was pretty long and corny. However, the actress that played Barney Fife was dead on. Cons: Rude waitstaff, Bad food more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 3 Next >
Menu for Agatha's Mystery Theatre


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

A Taste of Mystery

Owner Message

  • Agatha's isn't your regular Dinner Theatre with amateur actors trying to make it in show business. The Talent that has entertained Agatha's audiences throughout the years, and continues to do so 6 nights a week, are some the brightest, funniest, and most successful actors in the Southeast. We pride ourselves on having the best actors and actresses, not only in Atlanta, but anywhere. So here are just some of the amazing actors that are currently appearing or have appeared in productions at Agatha's throughout the years. We're proud to have all of them in the Agatha's family. You've seen them at Agatha's, as well as on popular network television shows, feature films, and some have even gone on to work with the historic Second City Improv troupe in Chicago.. Restaurants,Theaters

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Sure, getting entertainment with your meal in this town is no problem. But if you crave more interaction with your meal, try Agatha's--A Taste of Mystery, Atlanta's best shot at...

  • 6/27/2006 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: mon 07:30pm-10:00pm, tue 07:30pm-10:00pm, wed 07:30pm-10:00pm, thu 07:30pm-10:00pm, fri 08:00pm-10:30pm, sat 07:30pm-10:00pm, sun 06:00pm-08:30pm
  • Payments: Visa, Master Card, American Express, Diner's Club, Discover
  • Neighborhoods: Downtown, Northeast
badge