Agatha's Mystery Theatre

Claim
marker

161 Peachtree Center Ave
Atlanta, GA 30303

marker
(404) 584-2255
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Agatha's Mystery Theatre - Atlanta, GA
Reviews
( 14 )
( 12 )
( 6 )
( 2 )
( 14 )

Best

We've all been there, trying to find some fun social activity that means NOT hanging out in a bar. Agatha's is the place to go! Reserve your seats and be prepared to enjoy delici...

Worst

This was not at all what i expected. I expected a mystery, however, it was a musical spoof. The 2 actors were entertaining, however, all guests have a speaking part that isn't op...

TWO actors where missing 2/22/2009

Soo I had fun a long time ago when I went and I dont mean to be rude but there were only TWO people not the 4 .. they never even explaned why the other TWO actors where missing !? Pros: entertaning more

TWO actors where missing 2/22/2009

Soo I had fun a long time ago when I went and I dont mean to be rude but there were only TWO people not the 4 .. they never even explaned why the other TWO actors where missing !?\r \r Amber Nash & Marc Farley. were great !\r \r Emily Turner, Emilio Perey, where MIA \r \r so......does this mean its only 1/2 price ? \r \r food : *** ( waiters seemed in the background )\r service: ***\r Decor: *** ( like a planet hollywood but just with photos )\r Cost: ** Pros: entertaning more

TOTAL ripoff 7/24/2008

I went to Agatha's for my friend's birthday dinner. She had made reservations the week before for 10, but told them she wasn't sure how many people would come. They said "No big deal, It's your birthday!" And took her credit card number to hold the reservation. Only 4 people showed up to her party. Which is sad enough on your birthday but then she found out the next day that Agatha's charged her credit card $360 for the 6 people who didn't come!! I called them on her behalf (I thought she shouldn't have to deal with that on her birthday) and the woman was very snippy and said it was just their "policy" and nothing could be done about it. I think it's horrible to take $360 from someone for NOTHING, particularly on their birthday. What a bad way to run a business. I will never go back. more

TOTAL ripoff 7/24/2008

I went to Agatha's for my friend's birthday dinner. She had made reservations the week before for 10, but told them she wasn't sure how many people would come. They said ""No big deal, It's your birthday!"" And took her credit card number to hold the reservation. Only 4 people showed up to her party. Which is sad enough on your birthday but then she found out the next day that Agatha's charged her credit card $360 for the 6 people who didn't come!! I called them on her behalf (I thought she shouldn't have to deal with that on her birthday) and the woman was very snippy and said it was just their ""policy"" and nothing could be done about it. I think it's horrible to take $360 from someone for NOTHING, particularly on their birthday. What a bad way to run a business. I will never go back. more

Worth every penny! 6/25/2008

My friend and I were both interested in this sort of dining experience, so I bought us a couple tickets for a weekday showing. One of the actors greeted us at the door, explained roughly how things would go and gave us each our speaking parts. There was a cash bar there and a large spread of appetizers. The seating is more like a large dining hall, but the staff was attentive to our needs. \r The experience was really unique and both of us had a great time. The food was excellent, served in several courses with complimentary red or white wine a couple times throughout the evening. The actors did a wonderful job of getting the audience to participate. There were people who flopped and some who appeared as if they were auditioning, but everyone seemed to have a good time. If you're open minded, don't mind a couple lines of public speaking and want a full evening of entertainment, drinks and dinner, Agatha's is the placed. We loved it and plan to go back. more

Worth every penny! 6/25/2008

My friend and I were both interested in this sort of dining experience, so I bought us a couple tickets for a weekday showing. One of the actors greeted us at the door, explained roughly how things would go and gave us each our speaking parts. There was a cash bar there and a large spread of appetizers. The seating is more like a large dining hall, but the staff was attentive to our needs. more

Something New for a Friday Night! 9/14/2006

I recently visited Agatha's with my husband for his birthday. It was incredible! From the minute you walk in everyone is in character and making you laugh. You are also given a ""role"" in the play whether it is a speaking part (my husband got one b/c it was his birthday) or just a small part (I had to stand up and sing a song), everyone is involved. \r The food was good, as well. I was a little skeptical about it to begin with b/c of some of the other reviews, but I thought it was fine. There was a whole table of appetizers to choose from when we walked in and every course the rest of the night was tasty. The only complaint I have is that the entrees only come with 2 vegetables so if you don't like them (which I didn't) you don't get completely full. There is wine going around all night, though, so that makes up for it.\r In all, I had a great time, and I will definately be going back. This in my opinion makes a great spot to take relatives or friends from out of town, first dates, and anyone celebrating a birthday. So much fun!! \r Pros: Convenient parking, great seats no matter where you sit, Wonderful service Cons: Didn't like the vegetables that came with dinner and I didn't get completely full more

Something New for a Friday Night! 9/14/2006

I recently visited Agatha's with my husband for his birthday. It was incredible! From the minute you walk in everyone is in character and making you laugh. You are also given a "role" in the play whether it is a speaking part (my husband got one b/c it was his birthday) or just a small part (I had to stand up and sing a song), everyone is involved. Pros: Convenient parking, great seats no matter where you sit, Wonderful service Cons: Didn't like the vegetables that came with dinner and I didn't get completely full more

Great Show for bad food 2/10/2006

It's a "different" enviroment then most resturants but the food is terrible for the price they charge. The performers are definitely talented but again they charge way to much for food. Cons: Food more

Great Show for bad food 2/10/2006

It's a ""different"" enviroment then most resturants but the food is terrible for the price they charge. The performers are definitely talented but again they charge way to much for food. Cons: Food more

No Talent, Bad Food 5/20/2004

I thought the show was corny and the food was like eating at a bus station at 3 in the morning in a rural area. The service was worse than Mcdonalds, and way to fast paced, no one here cares how happy or un happy you are since they already have your money. Not a very comfortable setting for dinner and a show.,,,what a mess. Pros: location, parking Cons: , crappy food, stupid show more

No Talent, Bad Food 5/20/2004

I thought the show was corny and the food was like eating at a bus station at 3 in the morning in a rural area. The service was worse than Mcdonalds, and way to fast paced, no one here cares how happy or un happy you are since they already have your money. Not a very comfortable setting for dinner and a show.,,,what a mess. Pros: location, parking Cons: , crappy food, stupid show more

AWESOME and FUNNY 2/6/2004

I loved the show, it was funny, the staff was nice and efficient and the food was great. I went for my birthday with friends anf family and had a blast. I can't wait to go back and I highly recommend this to anyone, even kids can participate in the show, I saw all kinds of different people of all ages there. Pros: The Food, The Show, Great Waitstaff more

AWESOME and FUNNY 2/6/2004

I loved the show, it was funny, the staff was nice and efficient and the food was great. I went for my birthday with friends anf family and had a blast. I can't wait to go back and I highly recommend this to anyone, even kids can participate in the show, I saw all kinds of different people of all ages there. Pros: The Food, The Show, Great Waitstaff more

Unique 11/8/2003

The food was good, but not great like the service, but the show was entertaining and it was fun to have part in the show. I'm glad I went once for the experience (my anniversary) but would not return. Very social as you are seated in groups. Pros: unlimited wine, social Cons: poor service, mass food service, no parking more

Unique 11/8/2003

The food was good, but not great like the service, but the show was entertaining and it was fun to have part in the show. I'm glad I went once for the experience (my anniversary) but would not return. Very social as you are seated in groups. Pros: unlimited wine, social Cons: poor service, mass food service, no parking more

Fun! 7/21/2003

Enjoyed myself. The interaction was wonderful. Great group activity. Go with a positive attitude and knowing you will be asked to participate and will have fun. Food was good, but wasn't the highlight of the evening. Felt it was worth the money, and would be willing to go back with a group of friends or coworkers. more

Fun! 7/21/2003

Enjoyed myself. The interaction was wonderful. Great group activity. Go with a positive attitude and knowing you will be asked to participate and will have fun. Food was good, but wasn't the highlight of the evening. Felt it was worth the money, and would be willing to go back with a group of friends or coworkers. more

It was great! 5/3/2003

We showed up with 117 high school students and had a great time. The food could have been better, in terms of presentation, BUT, when you have to feed approximately 200 people in between acts and bus the tables before the play starts again, they did a great job. The wait staff was extemely pleasant kept up with the crowds needs. It's pure fun and a great experience if you are wanting to do something completly different. Pros: friendly staff, great entertainment, easy parking Cons: mediocre food more

It was great! 5/3/2003

We showed up with 117 high school students and had a great time. The food could have been better, in terms of presentation, BUT, when you have to feed approximately 200 people in between acts and bus the tables before the play starts again, they did a great job. The wait staff was extemely pleasant kept up with the crowds needs. It's pure fun and a great experience if you are wanting to do something completly different. Pros: friendly staff, great entertainment, easy parking Cons: mediocre food more
< Previous 1 2 3 Next >
Menu for Agatha's Mystery Theatre


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

A Taste of Mystery

Owner Message
  • Agatha's isn't your regular Dinner Theatre with amateur actors trying to make it in show business. The Talent that has entertained Agatha's audiences throughout the years, and continues to do so 6 nights a week, are some the brightest, funniest, and most successful actors in the Southeast. We pride ourselves on having the best actors and actresses, not only in Atlanta, but anywhere. So here are just some of the amazing actors that are currently appearing or have appeared in productions at Agatha's throughout the years. We're proud to have all of them in the Agatha's family. You've seen them at Agatha's, as well as on popular network television shows, feature films, and some have even gone on to work with the historic Second City Improv troupe in Chicago.. Restaurants,Theaters

Editorial
  • The Scene
    Sure, getting entertainment with your meal in this town is no problem. But if you crave more interaction with your meal, try Agatha's--A Taste of Mystery, Atlanta's best shot at...

  • 6/27/2006 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: mon 07:30pm-10:00pm, tue 07:30pm-10:00pm, wed 07:30pm-10:00pm, thu 07:30pm-10:00pm, fri 08:00pm-10:30pm, sat 07:30pm-10:00pm, sun 06:00pm-08:30pm
  • Payments: Visa, Master Card, American Express, Diner's Club, Discover
  • Neighborhoods: Downtown, Northeast
badge