Last Christmas Eve was spent at the West Street Grill where four of us were sat at a table that could not fit more than three people. This year, we decided to return because of the restaurant's proximity and because we had gone to the restaurant in person over a month ahead of time to make a reservation for any table other than the one we had been sat at. That is why we were shocked to learn, as we arrived there two nights ago, that we were to be sat at the very table we had been sat at the year before. When we asked for a different table, and explained that we had made a reservation well in advance in order to avoid being sat at a table that does not fit four people comfortably, we were told that WE were being unreasonable, that they couldn't have possibly promised us a particular table, and that we would have to wait. At 8:30pm we were told that the kitchen was closing and that we would have to order from the bar while we waited for a normal size table to be cleared. Because it was Christmas Eve we all decided to take this ridiculous demand in stride, but again reminded the owners how unfortunate it was that our reservation had not been honored and that instead of being inexplicably angry at US he should understand that the customer is always right. His reaction was shocking. ""NO, that's not true,"" he replied. At this point all of us decided to get our coats and leave. I will never forget what shameless, disgusting treatment my hosts and I had suffered at the West Street Grill. The establishment is categorized as a restaurant, when in fact it's essentially a private eating club. The food at this club, as I recall from last year, is good, but I would never want to be a member. And since it's all too eager to have George Clooney as one, I'm not quite sure why he would want to be one either.
Cons: Terrible service, horrible attitude, rude owners!
more