Two Guys is the only remaining AmerItalian restaurant since the closing of Brothers in Spring 2005. The "value" varies depending on what you order - some dishes are worth the price; other's aren't. The good news is nothing is terribly expensive. I'm personally a fan of the Wolfpack Special (steak sandwich on a kaiser roll with fries for $5.25) and the Grilled Chicken Caesar salad (roughly $6.50 - great way to get a salad on Hillsborough St.) while my roommate favors the Calzones. The staff is pretty friendly and is very accomidating for large groups (though we always call and warn them, a day in advance if possible, if we're more than 10 in number).
The croutons are absolutely amazing. If nothing else, make sure you have some croutons!
more