Three Boys from Italy, a small restaurant on Route 59, has BY FAR the best chicken parm in Rockland. I have been eating there for years- and, while it is not 100% consistent, when it is on (which is almost always), it is great. The pizza is also exceptional.
The only drawback to the chicken parm is the salad is just okay, and VERY basic, and the bread leaves a lot to be desired. The pasta (choice of spaghetti or penne) is great, and the chicken parm makes up for any other letdowns.
Also check out: pizza, baked ziti
more