The Cookie Cottage

Claim
marker

1551 Arlington
Hilliard, OH 43026

marker
(614) 325-0571
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:

Bakeries

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Photos
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
The Cookie Cottage - Hilliard, OH
Reviews
( 12 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

The cookies from The Cookie Cottage are absolutely delicious! All of them! I have orderred several varieties for friends for Christmas, birthdays and other occasions. I live in Pi...

Worst

All reviews seem positive

Editorial review from Citysearch 4/6/2013

The Cookie Cottage has moved to 1551 Arlington Ave., Marble Cliff, OH. Same phone. more
Reply | Report abuse |

The best cookies ever! 10/8/2011

The cookies from The Cookie Cottage are absolutely delicious! All of them! I have orderred several varieties for friends for Christmas, birthdays and other occasions. I live in Pittsford, New York so they are sent to me by overnight mail. They are so well packaged that they arrive fresh and whole. I recommend The Cookie Cottage to all of you who love homemade cookies! Anne Shaw Fenstermacher more
Reply | Report abuse |

Cookies are Great!! 6/30/2011

The cookies from Cookie Cottage in Hilliard are simply delicious! I have bought many flavors but really like the spice, choc choc chip, and shortbread cookies. The special shortbread at Valentines are quite a treat--with a choc dipped edge! I highly recommend the Cookie Cottage. \r more
Reply | Report abuse |

Better than Homemade! 6/27/2011

I have had these cookies often, both delivered to my house and shipped to Denver and they are always delicious. These cookies are perfect every time you order them. All of the flavors are better than I can make at home. My favorite is the peanut butter, or, the double chocolate chip, or, the kitchen sink... I just can't decide! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Scrumptious homemade cookies! 6/24/2011

Truly homemade flavor and texture — simply delicious cookies! My taste buds are dancing! Terrific service, too. I have enjoyed ordering these cookies and have sent them as a gift across the country — all to rave reviews! Love the way the cookies are packaged, too. Mine arrived by UPS in perfect condition. Applause! Applause! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Delicious homemade cookies! Yummmm!! 11/5/2010

I have received these cookies on many occasions as gifts and it has always been a great delight! I am especially a fan of the cranberry oatmeal ones, which are just heavenly, but I have yet to try a flavor I did not like. I love the homemade flavor- so much better than buying from a store! :) Try these cookies now! They are great to send to family far from home, to serve at parties or just as a snack! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Awesome Cookies! 4/9/2010

If I could rate 6 Stars, I would! My favorites are The Cranberry-White chocolate-Oatmeal. They are wonderful with Tea. Also, try the M&Ms. She has different colors for all the holidays and graduations! Pros: Each cookies is worth every calorie! Cons: The only drawback is when they are gone! more
Reply | Report abuse |

YUM YUM YUM 4/4/2010

These cookies are delicious and there is a good variety of selections. The molasses are to die for and I'm also a big fan of the chocolate chip. All orders are attractively packaged so they make nice gifts. Pros: Really homemade more
Reply | Report abuse |

Without a doubt the best cookies I have ever had! 3/12/2010

The taste of these cookies exceed those of any other cookie I have ever had. The cookies are usually mailed but can be delivered to anybody in the Columbus, OH area. Either way, they consistently taste fresh and always hit the spot! I would recommend no other brand of cookies but these! Pros: Great, agreeable service and fresh, delicious cookies. Cons: No negatives as far as I'm concerned. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Fresh Homemade Cookies in Columbus! 3/12/2010

The taste and texture of these cookies are what make them unique. I have been very successful freezing them also. Whether I have just purchased them, or have just defrosting them, they taste like they came from the oven. Pros: Taste like they were just baked. Cons: Fresh ingredients with no additives. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Delicious Homemade Cookies with no kitchen mess! 3/11/2010

Fresh baked cookies, baked to order and delivered locally or mailed to recipients. We have used Cookie Cottage Cookies for family reunions, student gifts, parties and corporate gifts. They arrive fresh, attractively packaged, and delicious. Invariably, people ask where we got them and ask for either the Cookie Cottage's webpage or telephone number so they can order for their own student, client or party! Pros: Delicious cookies, great convenience and service Cons: Fresh baked to order so you cannot get them off the shelf more
Reply | Report abuse |

Delicious Cookies! 3/11/2010

Cookie Cottage cookies are super delicious. The shortbread are buttery and light, the oatmeal are addicting and the colored M & M are fun for any occasion. I have used the Cookie Cottage to send special occasion gifts to clients and they always arrive on time, fresh and in attractive packaging. Delicious choice for cookies for yourself or to share with friends. I highly recommend them. LOVE THEM! Pros: Great Gifts more
Reply | Report abuse |

Yummy Cookies!! 3/11/2010

Cookies from the Cookie Cottage are made at home. :- ) They are delicious! There is a nice variety of choices. If you choose to mail them, they are packaged attractively and arrive fresh. They are truly yummy!! Pros: Delicious homemade cookies!! more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for The Cookie Cottage


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

The Cookie Cottage is a home-baking cookie business offering homemade cookies that are not frozen and have no preservatives or additives.

Owner Message

  • The Cookie Cottage is a home-baking cookie business offering a variety of cookies to please the palate and we are confident you'll find exactly what you are looking for. Our cookies taste homemade because they are homemade and each cookie is baked to order. No one cookie is frozen or has preservatives or additives. We offer a variety of cookie packages, care packages, desserts for when you are on a schedule, a great center piece for a party or special occasion. The Cookie Cottage cookie selection offers holiday cookies for Halloween, Christmas, Easter, Mother's Day, etc.; as well as congrats for a new baby, wedding or graduation. We also offer cookie pop bouquets, cookie tarts and more. Visit our website and if you don?t see exactly what you are looking for give us a call; We would be happy to discuss your party or event with you and accommodate your baking needs, whatever they be.

Additional information
  • Hours: Open Monday-Friday, 8:00 to 5:00 & Saturdays and Sundays as needed.
  • Neighborhoods: River Landings, Northwest Columbus
badge