Susan Magan Catering

Susan was wonderful to work with; very nice and very accommodating to our needs and menu ideas. The staff was professional, the presentation was beautiful, and the food was great. We got many nice compliments from our guests, and several asked for her name to cater their own parties. We were also impressed by how thoroughly they cleaned up afterwards, which is always a nightmare after a large party. I give her my highest recommendation. more

Good: She was easy to work with and very accommodating to our wishes and menu ideas. The presentation was beautiful and the food was great. We got many nice compliments from the guests who attended our party. Price was reasonable. I have already recommended this caterer to a couple of different friends.. Other: We were very impressed by their professionalism and also how efficiently and thoroughly they cleaned up afterwards. Cleaning up after a party is always a nightmare, but they did an outstanding job.. more

was not happy with the timing of the food and most everything was cold more

Susan's buffet table's are amazing. The food is solid, never trendy and the presentation is so classic. I don't understand all the references to "catholic" (sic) events from critics. I am Catholic, have been to many events catered by Susan given by the Archbishop, and everyone is happy. more

I am curious who the critics are - as what they say is completely unfounded but wreaks of competitive jealousy and revenge...Susan is an amazing cook and knows this industry like the back of her hand. Her advice is solid, her choices reliable and her crews always dependable - not to mention that you can't beat her prices. Perhaps this is why she doesn't advertise - she doesn't have to! No question about it...spectacular food and service at a great price! more

FYI!! Arch B's review may be somewhat tainted as she was caught one night smoking illegal drugs in the rear parking lot of an event that was catered by SMC. SMC then reacted by correcting the situation and reporting those involved and terminating contact...this may explain such a review by a bitter employee and her friends that followed with similar smear reviews! This is pathetic. To set the record straight, no Tiffany ever hired SMC in 2008! These smears are unfounded and outright lies. "Arch B" you are a weight challenged liar who has some explaining to do...perhaps in confession?! more

Susan's food is unbelievable. She's very professional, organized, and experienced. You can turn your party over to Susan and just relax. I cannot say enough about the quality of her food. Simply delicious! You'll never use another caterer after Susan. more

I used Susan Magan to cater an event and many people got ill from the food she served. Never again!! more

Couldn't have done it without her and her staff! I know why the Catholics hire her - she is from heaven and her staff and crew are the angels from above! Thanks to her I had the day I always dreamed of!!! more

I do not recommend this caterer. more

When I was planning my wedding 2 years ago, I chose a location that had a list of preferred providers. I contacted the top 3 based on a tasting event, and Susan was the best combination of great food, beautiful presentation and reasonable pricing. We knew she would follow through, and the food was even more incredible than we could have imagined. We had her prepare the food for the rehearsal dinner as well, and we received rave reviews from all of our guests for how great the food was. Several people mentioned it was the best food they had ever had at a wedding, more like a great restaurant experience. Susan has a real love for food and entertaining, and she is a wonderful person to boot. I would recommend her to anyone that needs a caterer. more