Red Elephant Pizza & Grill

Almost every time I go here, I get the Siesta Key Salad and pita chips. It's so great, the honey mustard dressing is fantastic (tastes housemade, not from a bottle), and the pita chips are always crispy! The service is insanely fast too. Last time I went I tried the ahi tuna appetizer, and the tuna was incredibly fresh and was a beautiful color. The dipping sauces it was served with were great too. 2 thumbs up from me!! more

This is my favorite Red Elephant location in Tally. We get seated fairly quickly, the staff is outstanding, and the hostesses are very nice. If there's a wait, someone's there to give out samples of appetizers, which is a great idea. The burgers are perfect, fries are as well, and the pizza is fresh and has great toppings and I love the crust. Everything tastes house made instead of from a box or freezer. My girlfriend and I love going here. more

Red Elephant's pizza is fresh, with a house-made crust, but their other menu items are equally as good: fun salads, grilled fish salmon or mahi, healthy choices such as steamed broccoli or grilled chicken, crispy pita chips with hummus, juicy burgers, and their own unique ""elephant ears"", which is a must-try (and be prepared to share!). What I like is that the menu has just enough variety without having an overwhelming amount of items to choose from. You can tell the place is managed well, because the service is always top notch. It's well-run, which is essential for a place that is really busy, especially on weekends. It's very family-friendly too, with a game room for the kids and a kids' menu that has a good variety. Prices are surprisingly reasonable. The atmosphere is fun and lively, the place is clean. This location is very convenient, well-sized, and runs like a well-oiled machine. more