Potato Brumbaugh's

Hey, don't waste your time on this one... it's closed. If anyone knows how to get this listing off the site, do it. There's an intreaguing new sportsbar in the new building though. Cons: it's closed! more

I arrived late around 9 PM There were only about 15-20 people dining in the restaurant and I was seated at a table in back that was partially shared with another couple obviously sharing a romantic dinner. I felt awkward sitting there and asked to be seated at another table. Then I was seated next to a large group of people and I still felt like I was invading the privacy of their group setting. The majority of the tables in the restaurant were available. I was then offered the opportunity to move again by a more experienced wait person who noticed the situation. From that point on everything went well. The food was exceptional. I just think it was a matter of having someone new who was probably in training. Pros: Atmosphere, Good food, not crowded Cons: Expensive, Small Portions, Limited selection more

The food (including potatoes) is great! I have never had a better meal. The service was excellent, especially one server in particular. The waiter served us very fast and the food was exceptional. If I were to tell you the best restaurant in all of Greeley, CO, Potato Brumbaugh's would be the one. It is Great!! Pros: Food, Good parking, Comfortable more