Pizzeria Scotty

Claim
marker

9809 W Oklahoma Ave (at 9809 W Oklahoma Ave Milwaukee, WI)
Milwaukee, WI 53227

marker
(414) 543-1300
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
Pizzeria Scotty - Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria Scotty - Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria Scotty - Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria Scotty - Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria Scotty - Milwaukee, WI
Reviews
( 8 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 2 )
( 0 )

Best

My girlfriend introduced me to there pizza and I have loved it ever since. They always have been prompt...

Worst

I purchased a groupon deal for this pizza joint otherwise I don't think I would have ever ordered from...

Editorial review from Citysearch 12/25/2015

Hands down best thin Chicago style pizza in Milwaukee. Deep dish is great too; it?s all in the ingredients. Sauce with just the right amount of zing, without being too sweet or tangy. Cheese that is just perfect without being greasy. But the sausage is absolutely out of this world, perfectly spiced. Generous portions of each. And many other great toppings too. I moved to Milwaukee from Chi town back in 95 and searched for years to find the perfect pizza since finding Pizzeria Scotty 3 years ago would never even try another place. And I really tried many before that. PS turned my Dentist and his family on to it in 2014 now he travels all the way from Brown Deer rd. when he needs a slice. more
Reply | Report abuse |

We did eat the pizza 12/1/2013

I purchased a groupon deal for this pizza joint otherwise I don't think I would have ever ordered from... more
Reply | Report abuse |

We did eat the pizza 12/1/2013

bwrighterbee Provided by Partner
I purchased a groupon deal for this pizza joint otherwise I don't think I would have ever ordered from them. The deal sounded like a great bargain... more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great pizza 11/7/2012

My girlfriend introduced me to there pizza and I have loved it ever since. They always have been prompt... more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great pizza 11/7/2012

Tigercobra Provided by Partner
My girlfriend introduced me to there pizza and I have loved it ever since. They always have been prompt with our orders and have never disappointed. more
Reply | Report abuse |

My Favorite Pizza Place! 11/4/2012

Pizzeria Scotty is by far my favorite pizza place. Whenever I go anywhere else and have pizza, I always see... more
Reply | Report abuse |

My Favorite Pizza Place! 11/4/2012

cinnamongirl Provided by Partner
Pizzeria Scotty is by far my favorite pizza place. Whenever I go anywhere else and have pizza, I always see how it holds up to Pizzeria Scotty. So ... more
Reply | Report abuse |

Excellent pizza! I order from here all 1/21/2012

Excellent pizza! I order from here all the time, and they deliver! It's always delicious! All of their pizza styles are great too! Pros: null Cons: null more
Reply | Report abuse |

Delicious Dough and Sauce 9/9/2010

I love pizza scotty. The friendly, fast delivery is tops. Ingredients are truly fresh and delicious. (1)... more
Reply | Report abuse |

Delicious Dough and Sauce 9/9/2010

Sanguine Provided by Partner
I love pizza scotty. The friendly, fast delivery is tops. Ingredients are truly fresh and delicious. more
Reply | Report abuse |

What A Pie! 8/31/2010

This is the Best delivered Pizza in Milwaukee! The Thin Crust is buttery & delicious. We order 3 times a month and everytime Perfect! The Brick oven cooks the pizza perfect, it offers a flavor no-one can compete with. Give them a try on a Saturday night when you don't feel like cooking - you will be back. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Chicago Style 11/17/2004

The best Chicago style pizza in Milwaukee! The sauce is southern/Sicilian, and it fills you up! The thin crust is very good, the pan style is awesome, and the stuffed pizza is huge! They also offer a very good EYE-talian beef and meatball sandwich. Pick up if possible, delivery time is long due to the length of time it takes to cook the pizzas. Pros: delicious, authentic, tasty more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great food, not-so-good service. 8/12/2002

If you can get past the sometimes rude demeanor of several of the employees there, you're in for a treat! Their thin crust, hand-tossed and double dough pizzas are all out of this world. During the week, they offer an "Early Bird" special where you can get a medium pizza for free w/ the order of a large. Pros: Delicious pizza, Good valu during week Cons: Sometimes rude srvice, Check your order! more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Pizzeria Scotty


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

NowThatsAPizza.com

Owner Message

  • Pizza,Specialty Pizza,Chicken,Appetizers,Side Orders,Pasta,Sandwiches,Beverages,Salads

    Pizzeria Scotty specializes in carry out and delivery. As such,we do not have a dining room or offer on-premise seating. We utilize a computerized order-taking system that makes placing your order quick and simple. If you choose to use a credit or debit card,that's no problem. We accept all major credit cards for pick up or delivery. We're open for lunch Monday through Friday at 11am offering delivery service to your home or business. On Saturday and Sunday,we open at 4pm.
    BRAND
    Home to Genuine Chicago Style Pizza
    * Guaranteed to Be Simply Superb!
    * Traditional Thin Crust Pizza
    * Double Dough Pizza
    * Chicago Pan Pizza
    * Stuffed Pizza
    Plus a Full Line of Italian Sandwiches Including:
    * Authentic Chicago Style Italian Beef
    * Italian Sausage and Meatball Sandwiches
    * Full Line of Pasta,and Homemade Marinara Sauce
    * Assortment of Appetizers

    In the Mood for Some Pasta?
    * We Offer a Full Line of Pasta Including Homemade Lasagna,Meat and Cheese Ravioli,Mostaciolli and Chicken Parmesan
    * All Topped with Our Savory Homemade Marinara Sauce!
    Got a Craving for Some Appetizers?
    * Breaded Mushrooms - Homemade Mozzarella Sticks
    * Deep Fried Garlic Bread Sticks - Chicken Nuggets
    * French Fries - Hot & Juicy Inferno Wings

Additional information
  • Hours: Mon-Fri 11am-9pm ; Sat 4pm-11pm ; Sun 4pm-11pm ; Open 7 Days
  • Payments: Visa, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods: West View
badge