Pet Supplies Plus in Oceanside opened July 2003. We offer the quantity and selection of a big box store, with the welcoming and personalized service of a neighborhood store. Our stores are known for having Long Island's largest selection of natural and holistic pet foods with popular brands such as Redford Naturals, Blue Buffalo, Wellness, Merrick, Natural Balance, Health Extension, and many more! We are the proud sponsor of the Eisenhower Dog Park as we are committed to enhancing our Long Island pet community.