About McDonald McGarry Insurance At McDonald McGarry, we know folks don’t want to buy insurance. From Homeowners to Auto Insurance, it can be confusing and costly. Ads tell you you’re in good hands, there’s a claims university or even, folks in white aprons who protect your home. No clever ads... just the confidence you are getting the insurance you need at a price you can afford. Our goal is simple – we want to make your insurance work for you.