I've lived in and around Plymouth for 17 years, and I keep coming back to Marcellos. Thin, flaky crust topped with succulant sauce and topping that are just short of an imtimate encounter. Some of the staff have been there for many years. There's a small town feel, and I get the sense it's because not many have found the experience and the taste that Marcellos has to offer. You see neighbours enjoying the tastes, the smells, and the sights in the open kitchen. There isn't an entree that I wouldn't recommend, though there are definitely entrees I cannot recommend since I can't seem to pull myself away from the lasagna or the pizza. If you're within 16,000 miles of Marcellos, you're within distance of the best pizza I've found.
Pros: sights, sounds, smells, tastes, staff, atmosphere, prices, overall ambience
Cons: on a busy night (Fridays and Saturdays), waits are a bit longer than usual, but still within acceptance, especially compared to the 30+ minutes you might be waiting at big chains
more