I expected Mama Gina's to be listed under Italian, not just pizza. This place makes fine traditional Italian food although it looks like a small pizza place. It is family run and is not a chain.
A friend who has been going for years told me about this place. We have had and love the chicken in garlic sauce, the vodka sauce, the fried calamari, the sausage, and the parmaggiana. We asked if they minded if we went across the street and buy a bottle of wine and they gave us a glass free from their big jug. I felt like I was family. I live three hours away and I still go every time Im on Long Island
Expect leftovers or order one entree less (three for 4 people) and a couple of slices as appetizer. And dont forget a bottle of Chianti from across the street.
Pros: Delicious, free wine, Price
Cons: , small parking lot
more