Kinchley's Tavern Inc.

I was going to school up in the Mahwah area and it took me awhile to discover this amazing reatraunt! If you like thin crust pizza then this place is a must! It's a small reatraunt and it's almost always packed! Don't even attempt a weekend night for your first visit because the crowd and wait will turn you off. But once you have tried the pizza you will be back for more and more! I especially love the Meatball pizza! It's reasonably priced but because it's so thin you tend to eat a lot more. And they have pretty cheap beer. Order by the pitcher.. thats the cheapest way. more

NYC loves it's thick, cheese swamped slices. and while there are outposts where you can get a thinner, more delicate slice, none I have seen come close to Kinchley's cracker thin crust. My Bergen County friends told me to go here if I wanted to experience the ultimate in thin crust pizza. My wife is a big fan of this variety and I have, over the years, been coming around to her point of view. The great thing about thin crust is that the sauce, spices and cheese shine; they are not overwhelmed by the dough. At Kinchley's, that's exactly what happens - you bite into a crispy crust and the satisfying tang of sauce and cheese mix perfectly while you enjoy the crunch. Mmmmm. This is really good pizza served in an old-time tavern atmosphere. No slices and the pies are small so order a big one and you won't be disappointed. Very crowded at lunch but worth the wait. more