I was visiting Madison for the weekend, and my boyfriend and I stopped for an early dinner at Key West Shrimp House. We split the Shrimp Panama and I was extremely disappointed. They were cooked, frozen shrimp that tasted a little fishy, and were seriously overcooked. The ""special sauce"" reminded me of Campbell's tomato soup with sugar. The double baked potato wasn't too bad, but it was obviously frozen, with that hard crust on top. According to my boyfriend, the salad bar and soup were OK. If we head back to Madison, it's a restaurant I would definately skip.
more