top 10

Jumping Jacks Seafood Shack

Claim
marker

140 Lewis Walk (at Ocean Walk)
Sayville, NY 11782

marker
(631) 597-4174
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 3 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

Best lobster roll I ever had. Seems like they coarsely chopped and ENTIRE Lobster (tail, claws, legs) and put it in between a tasty Croissant. Can't wait to return. Of course, ...

Worst

Just about the worst meal I've ever had at any price (and this one was expensive). Service was friendly, although he failed to mention the specials, never asked what we thought o...

Excellent Lobster Roll 8/13/2010

Best lobster roll I ever had. Seems like they coarsely chopped and ENTIRE Lobster (tail, claws, legs) and put it in between a tasty Croissant. Can't wait to return. Of course, being right on the beach is awesome. Antonio the bartender rocks (aka Robert) Try his drink-of-the-day special. Enjoy Anna Ava more

Loved it! 7/27/2009

Great food,Great time!!! more

Worst meal ever 8/24/2008

Just about the worst meal I've ever had at any price (and this one was expensive). Service was friendly, although he failed to mention the specials, never asked what we thought of the meal (wish he had), and was very quick with the check even though place was not very full. I should have just ordered fish and chips - fairly fool proof- but I wanted something interesting. I am not picky and just as happy with a burger or takeout chinese as fine dining, but this food was unbelievable even by takeout standards. My guest thought her meal was ok but I thought it was pretty bad. I actually had to remove the scallops from my mouth as they were inedible. Pizza place looked great; I'll be kicking myself for sometime to come that I didn't just eat there. Pros: drinks were good Cons: food horrible more

WOW! Need I say more. 5/27/2008

My Friends and I spent memorial day in fire island coming from NYC. it was our first time so we did not know what to expect. We got to fire island late around 4pm. went to a house party then time for drinks then another house party. lots of walking then we got very hungry so the nice man in the purple rhinestone shorts told us to go to cherry grove for dinner. So off we went walking (water taxi was not around) and walking finally we arrived to JUMPING JACKS! after a long day we have the BEST food ever! and the service was very inviting! the hostess who sat us told us she designed the menu herself so she told us what her specials were! as i gave all the wait staff light necklaces that I had in my purse as a gift. our food came! I had the Best shrimp & lobster pasta! My friend had the Tuna it was very fresh and cooked to perfection! Oh and the sangria was yummy! all in all we had the Best dinner the Best service and a great cozy relaxing time after a fun day!!! TWO THUMBS UP! ***** Pros: Best food on the island! Great service! Cozy Ambience! Try the sangria ;-) Cons: They don't deliver to Manhattan. lol more
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Jumping Jacks Seafood Shack


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial
  • In Short
    The oceanfront view--either from the dining room or the patio--is the restaurant's greatest asset. The menu mimics the surroundings, with lobster night every Friday, a raw bar on...

  • 8/24/2006 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Daily 11:30am-4am
  • Payments: Master Card, Visa, Discover, American Express
  • Neighborhoods: Fire Island, Long Island City, Long Island
badge