Downtown old Antioch around the corner from the Amtrak station on 2nd street. Andrea Vitale, the owner can order nearly anything you don't find there, but there's TONS of stuff to choose from. I can't seem to leave there without buying something really nice. I get great books there, icons, bookmarks, even a very nice silver rosary ring (no more lost rosaries!). About 2,000 square feet of everything Catholic. Wonderful store.
Pros: Books, videos, sacramental gifts, jewelry, statuary, art
Cons: None!
more