Every time I come into town, I just have to visit Gypsy Joe's. The chocolare peanut butter ice cream is to die for! We also love the strawberry, buter pecan, and banana flavors. This place is a must-see when your in Lancaster. One thing - they do close during the winter months, so you'll have to fight off your cravings when it's cold outside.
Pros: flavor, variety, fun tropical environment, price, offer ice cream cakes
Cons: sit on picnic benches, closed in winter months
more