top 10

Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar

Claim
marker

27-C Utter Ave
Hawthorne, NJ 07506

marker
(973) 744-1558
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Related categories:

Food & Dining

Photos
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar - Hawthorne, NJ
Reviews
( 3 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

These cupcakes were great! These cupcakes were soft and moist, and very tasty. Just perfect! All the ladies at work were so excited when I brought them into the office. My favorit...

Worst

After hearing good things about Gimme Jimmy's Cookies, we decided to try them and we were VERY disappointed!!! Cupcakes were stale! Worse than stale and had no flavor. Cookies w...

Awesome Cupcakes 1/26/2011

These cupcakes were great! These cupcakes were soft and moist, and very tasty. Just perfect! All the ladies at work were so excited when I brought them into the office. My favorites were the Red Velvet and the Chocolate Dipped Cannoli cupcakes. more
Reply | Report abuse |

VERY Disappointed 11/28/2010

After hearing good things about Gimme Jimmy's Cookies, we decided to try them and we were VERY disappointed!!! Cupcakes were stale! Worse than stale and had no flavor. Cookies were just as bad. $21.00 for 4 cupcakes and 2 small cookies. Wouldn't think twice about paying $21.00 for this if they were edible. Thankfully its garbage night as everything I purchased there today is in the trash! I will NOT be recommending Gimme Jimmy's to anyone! (Only gave this 1 star because I had to give it a rating--not worthy of any stars) more
Reply | Report abuse |

Happy again! 10/13/2009

I was sad to see Gimmee Jimmy's Cookies leave Montclair to Hawthorne. But I just found that I can order my favorite cookies on Amazon All I did was search Gimmee Jimmy's Cookies on the Amazon website. They do make the very best cookies I have ever eaten. Pros: the best cookies more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great place for desserts 10/10/2009

I went there a couple of months ago....and WOW!!! These cupcakes are sooooo yummy! They are nice and moist and they have way more to offer than the usual cupcake flavors. The frosting was sweet but 'not too sweet and the prices are cheap.... I tried the German Chocolate, red velvet, and the chocolate with peanut butter foam icing and I loved every bite of each cupcake I had. My boyfriend got a chocolate chocolate chip but I didn't get to try it. They have lot's of other flavors to choose from. I go to school in New York so I plan on visiting this place several times again to try their other flavors. Pros: Best cupcakes and cookies more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Gimmee Jimmy's Cookie Bar


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
badge