The Fish House ENCORE located just a long cast away from The Original Fish House, offers a dining experience unmatched in the Upper Keys! With an abundance of fresh seafood available, ENCORE prepares locally caught fish and shellfish - yellowtail snapper, grouper, mahi-mahi, lobster, stone crab and shrimp - in a variety of ways to satisfy the most discriminating tastes of its guests.. ENCORE prepares locally caught fish and shellfish - yellowtail snapper,grouper,mahi-mahi,lobster,stone crab and shrimp - in a variety of ways to satisfy the most discriminating tastes of its guests.