Circa 59 was decorated as beautifully as the rest of the hotel, truly giving The Parker a run for its money. Sadly, this is where the comparison ends. We went to the restaurant for a birthday dinner with great expectations. Unfortunately, what we got was a pretty gift box that opened up to reveal a lump of coal. When we got to the host stand, there was immediate pandemonium. No one seemed to know what was going on (which was the theme during the entire ordeal), but finally, we were seated right near a door, despite asking to be seated in one of the outside tables (having been told that those were already reserved for those who specifically requested them...note: no one sat in at least 3 of the tables during our 4 hour dining fiasco). We then were given menus with tiny flashlights to read by (a'la the Parker)...but only one tiny flashlight per table. When we asked for more than one so that we did not have to take turns, the waiter told us this was not possible. Somehow, we still somehow managed to order our meals. Very long story short, it took 4 hours for us to finish our meal (eating time was maybe a half an hour, as the food was atrocious when it did finally arrive): at least 3 times we were given the wrong food, the food that finally arrived was oversalted (Oysters Rockefeller should not have large pieces of rock salt floating on the bottom), overcooked, and completely sub-par & uninspired. When we complained, we were given free desert (Woopee), but not allowed to choose the desert ourselves, and the taste of the desert only confirmed that the pastry chef should be fired along with the chef and the rest of the dining room staff. Oh, and the restaurant's music was competing with the music from the Bikini Bar outside. So much for the great atmosphere. Bad service when a restaurant first opens can be expected and forgiven, so long as your food exceeds expectations. Sadly, the only expectations that Circa 59 exceeded were our lowest.
Pros: Decor
Cons: Food, Service, Lighting, everything else other than decor
more